The Scare Factor’s
“Scariest Haunted House” Awards

Below are the “Scariest Haunted House” Awards that have been given based on our review teams’ “Fright Effect” ratings during the 2017 Halloween haunt season. Also, we’ve included our “Highest Rated Haunt” award, which goes to the attraction with the highest overall review rating. Congratulations go out to each of these incredible haunted attractions!

*Note: The only States that were eligible for these “Scariest in State” awards include those with at least 10 haunted attractions that were reviewed by our Teams during the 2017 haunt season. This was to help us gather enough scores to create a fair and reasonable assessment of the attractions in that State.


Scariest Haunted House in Florida:
The Shallow Grave

Scariest Haunted House in Florida Shallow Grave

Haunted House Review

Rated 9.58 / 10 by Team Giraffic Shark


Scariest Haunted House in Illinois:
Dungeon of Doom

Scariest Haunted House in Illinois Dungeon of Doom

Haunted House Review

Rated 7.97 / 10 by Team White City Devils


Scariest Haunted House in Indiana:
Nightmare on Edgewood

Scariest Haunted House in Indiana Nightmare on Edgewood

Haunted House Review

Rated 8.96 / 10 by Team Zombillies


Scariest Haunted House in Kentucky:
The Haunted Hotel

Scariest Haunted House in Kentucky Haunted Hotel

Haunted House Review

Rated 9.5 / 10 by Team Zombillies


Scariest Haunted House in Michigan:
Corpse Barn Shock Haunt

Scariest Haunted House in Michigan Corpse Barn Shock Haunt

Haunted House Review

Rated 8.63 / 10 by Team Body Bag


Scariest Haunted House in New York:
Gateways Haunted Playhouse

Scariest Haunted House in New York Gateways Haunted Playhouse

Haunted House Review

Rated 9.37 / 10 by Team Hallowoosh


Scariest Haunted House in Ohio:
Wells Township Haunted House

Scariest Haunted House in Ohio Wells Township

Haunted House Review

Rated 8.97 / 10 by Team Mysterious Misery


Scariest Haunted House in Pennsylvania:
Scarehouse

Scariest Haunted House in Pennsylvania Scarehouse

Haunted House Review

Rated 9.18 / 10 by Team Scary Potter and the Hauntwarts Express


Scariest Haunted House in South Carolina:
Sweet Dreams Scare House

Scariest Haunted House in South Carolina Sweet Dreams Scarehouse

Haunted House Review

Rated 8.40 / 10 by Team Jefferson Starship


Highest Rated Haunt:
Dungeon of Doom Haunted House

Highest Rated Haunt Dungeon of Doom

Haunted House Review

Rated 7.97 / 10 by Team White City Devils