The Scariest Haunted Houses in Indiana for 2022
Are you looking for the scariest haunted houses in Indiana to visit for the 2022 Halloween haunt season?
You’ve come to the right place!
On this page, you will find the scariest haunted houses in Indiana for 2022. These haunts were selected from our list of national haunt rankings based on those that received a “Scare Factor” score of 8.0 or higher in the past 3 years. Our review teams look at how scary the haunt was, how well they provided scares to the entire group, how predictable the scares were, how many types of scares were received, and how strong the finale was to determine these scores. You can click on the haunt’s name to learn more about that attraction. You can also click the “Read the Full Review Here!” link to see exactly what makes each of these the scariest haunted houses in Indiana!
13: Fear Itself at Legend Park
14130 McKinley Hwy, Mishawaka, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2020 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.04/10
Each of the attractions targeted a variety of fears and phobias while using their emblematic approaches to dishing them out to us! We were impressed by the number of psychological scares that were encountered here, too. Rock Monkey Caves: 7.61 It was difficult for us to let our guard down in this. . .12: Evil on Erie
1240 Erie Street, Lafayette, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2021 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.1/10
We weren’t quite sure what to expect out of a haunt we simply hadn’t heard much about. But, we are happy to report that they successfully scared us in a variety of ways! This haunt is an excellent representation of how far creativity can go over a large budget. There were six members in our group,. . .11: Unreal Nightmares
117 South Meridian Street, Jasonville, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2021 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.11/10
Unreal Nightmares takes quite a unique approach with its method of scaring. We didn’t encounter many jump scares here. Instead, the haunt is built to instill suspense in such a way that your group won’t catch up to any others. This does result in a longer wait to get in, but we think you’ll agree. . .10: Cemetery of the Damned at Necropolis Underground Haunted Attractions
7130 Western Select Drive, Indianapolis, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2022 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.13/10
The night started strong with startles and scares, but the last two haunts lost some scaring steam as we progressed. The complex was built with hundreds, if not thousands, of hidey holes throughout, and when the cast can utilize them, we guarantee they’ll at least get a jump out of you. There’s no. . .9: Horror House Haunt
28051 Moore Drive, West Harrison, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2020 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.23/10
It was obvious that this wasn’t this group’s first rodeo at providing scares. Overall, the denizens within the motel had very good timing! When they made their appearances, they were so quick it was nearly impossible to pick them off. A variety of scares from aggressive acting, sliding actors. . .From Our 2021 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.35/10
Fear Fair always manages to squeeze out a squeak or scream from one of the members of our group, and this year was no different. Several effectively camouflaged hiding spots got both of us at the same time! Although many of the scareactors were hidden well or sneaky, there were some larger areas. . .7: Nightmare House at Necropolis Underground Haunted Attractions
7130 Western Select Drive, Indianapolis, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2022 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.33/10
The night started strong with startles and scares, but the last two haunts lost some scaring steam as we progressed. The complex was built with hundreds, if not thousands, of hidey holes throughout, and when the cast can utilize them, we guarantee they’ll at least get a jump out of you. There’s no. . .6: Malice Manor
640 Providence Way, Clarksville, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2022 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.4/10
The effects and creatures derived from Rancor’s desires continue to grow fiercer, making the manor a scarier place to visit. Scares were spread throughout the members of our group evenly as they targeted each of us a fair amount of times. No one was safe! Various fears were bestowed: giant and. . .5: Criminally Insane
226 South Main Street, Crown Point, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2020 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.45/10
CI does have a number of good jump scares throughout and the crowds really seem to react in a proper scared way! Every actor we encountered did great on providing scares to everyone in our group as well, making no one safe no matter the position in line. I do feel CI does a great job on catering to. . .4: The Thirteenth Hour
915 South Shortridge Rd, Indianapolis, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2020 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.49/10
Not long after we started our journey, we noticed they were focused on delivering more, and more-diverse scares this season. Right off the bat, they singled one of us out and changed things up by making a different person in our group lead the line. They continued to reiterate that one of us would. . .3: Fright Manor
350 Anniston Drive, Indianapolis, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2021 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.58/10
There were several loud noises, excited and murderous cast members, claustrophobia (which is one of our group’s greatest fears), several whirring weapons, and pitch-black darkness that were all used together to create a cohesive and frightening show. There were plenty of actors in each room and they. . .From Our 2020 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 8.92/10
The actors in HHH clearly know and understand the art of the scare. As accustom as we have become by now in terms of being frightened, HHH actors always find ways to misdirect or jump scare and still affect us properly. When combined with amazing scenes and props, these constant scares are effective. . .1: Nightmare on Edgewood
1959 S Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN(Click for More Info)
From Our 2022 Review:
Scare Factor Rating: 9.15/10
From beginning to end, we never knew who or what would attack us next. They kept us on our toes the entire time. Scares were directed at everyone in our group, not just the front or the back. The denizens in all three haunts don’t know what personal space is, so they will get up close and personal. . .We hope you enjoyed our list of the scariest haunted attractions in Indiana to visit for 2022!
Remember, only haunts that we’ve reviewed in the past 3 years (to date) that received a “Scare Factor” score of 8.0 or higher were considered for this list. If you’re looking for an entire list of all haunted houses in Indiana that we’ve ever reviewed, please visit our HAUNT REVIEWS page. If you’re looking for an entire list of all haunted houses in Indiana, please visit our HAUNT DIRECTORY page. If you enjoy watching haunted house walkthrough videos, check out our YOUTUBE CHANNEL. We hope to see you at a haunt someday, but until then, Happy Haunting!