Dayton Scream Park Review (2012)

Final Score7.43/10
8 categories scored
Scariness
Moderate ScaresModerate Scares

Summary

2012 marks Nightmare on Valley Street’s 10th year in operation on their action-packed haunts covering over 20 acres. All-new this year is the Hillbilly Hayride: An Offroad Experience, where you can bring your kids and anyone else that’s ‘too chicken for the trail!’ Nightmare on Valley Street brings you over 30 scenes, over 40 live monsters, and attempts to capture those who make it through the trail in Rat Trap, a demented AND difficult haunted maze! If you’re in the Dayton, Ohio area this year, don’t overlook Nightmare on Valley Street for this year’s haunt season!

Cast7.57

The cast consists of between 100-120 interactive and volunteer actors that take pride in the construction of the trail each year. The sheer number of actors fills up each attraction and helps eliminate dead spots. Each actor (or group of actors) gets to build their own scene and design their own scares to their own twisted likings. As a result, if you’re looking for a variety of characters, this is the place to go! These guys and gals have a little bit of everything to offer. From crazy savages and monsters to skeletons and trolls, it’s here! Among our favorite… Read More…

Costuming7.02

Because each actor was in charge of their own wardrobe, some characters fit their scenes more appropriately than others. Also, some costumes/makeup/masks were more elaborate than others, depending on what each actor was able to provide. However, the haunt does have a few artists on-staff to help each actor prepare.

Customer Service8.05

The attraction was a little difficult for us to find. We finally realized that an orange highway sign is used that says ‘Hayride 1500 feet, Haunted Trail’ with arrows pointing you in the right direction. We didn’t notice it immediately because we saw the barricade and were accustomed to thinking that it meant the road was closed, when this wasn’t the case. We followed the rest of the signs and found a large, gravel parking lot with portable restrooms when we arrived. An attendant was also present at the gate to point us towards the best parking spot available. The… Read More…

Atmosphere6.79

The first things we noticed as we approached the ticket booth was the bonfire, the sounds of those screaming on the trail and the special effects used in the two haunted attractions as they echoed up from the woods! We could also hear loud music coming from loudspeakers playing a local radio station. The rustic, cabin-style ticket booth and makeup on some of the staff let us know we were at a haunted house. Between haunts, Nightmare on Valley Street’s hearse was located next to the trail for us to see.

Special Effects7.74

The wide variety of special effects in this attraction helped improve the haunt as a whole because there were many things we had never seen before. Special rubber mats helped the actors’ distraction techniques and kept us off balance. Multiple ‘motorized attacks’ seemed to be a specialty of this haunt and they were used very effectively throughout the attraction. Another interesting effect was an actors use of ropes to catch us off guard from above! More motorized techniques were used in Rat Trap along with lots and lots of sheets to make the maze even more disorienting.

Theme7.11

Each actor or group of actors was permitted to create their own theme for each scene. As a result, no specific theme was designated for the attraction without being more specific than ‘things that scare people.’ However, Rat Trap’s theme was obviously a haunted maze designed to entrap those who made it through the trail, but still contained several different genres of scares.

Scare Factor7.47

It was fairly easy to predict what type of scare was coming up throughout the trail, but we never knew exactly when or what was going to scare us! Distraction was used occasionally and scares ranged from actors falling from trees and wrenches banging next to us to motorized vehicle scares and a caged prisoner swinging from a tree. For the trail, we found that most of the scares were directed towards the front of the line, but those in the back got some scares as well! Our group got separated multiple times throughout Rat Trap which helped take us… Read More…

Entertainment & Value7.66

General admission to the Nightmare on Valley Street is $12 for the trail only. Rat Trap and the Hillbilly Hayride are an additional $10 each, but kids 5 and under can experience the Hayride for free(which is a dark off-road experience with no monsters)! A combo ticket can be purchased for $25 that will grant you access to all three attractions. A $2 off coupon can be printed off their website applicable to the trail. We estimated that it took our group from 40 minutes to an hour to make it through the trail and escape the Rat Trap, making… Read More…

Know Before You Go

  • Family Friendly
  • Food/Concessions
  • Gift Shop/Souvenirs
  • Indoor/Outdoor
  • Movie Characters
  • Original Characters
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site
  • Uncovered Outdoor Waiting Line

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2024Haunt AwardDeadliest Duo (2024 – Team Zombillies)Freddy and Jason
2024Haunt AwardScariest Actor (2024 – Team Zombillies)Leatherface
2024Shout out Award(2024 – Team Zombillies)Plumber Joe AKA David Carey
2015Haunt AwardBest Hiding Spots (2015 – Team Mysterious Misery)
2012Shout out Award(2012 – Team Zombillies)Werewolf

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Guest Review by hellohellion

Rating:
Visited: 10/11/2025 | Recommended: ❌ No

What They Liked Most:
The walk-through haunt is long. It took us 40 minutes to walk through the whole thing. Some of the set dressing is admirable, and the portion of the h... Read More

Suggested Improvements:
A psychologically painful experience, and not for the reasons you'd hope. There are two attractions: a hayride and walk-through "maze&qu... Read More

Guest Review by Mike

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/14/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
What a great haunt. I remember this from years ago and it has grown to an even better attraction. The Actors provided true realism to their scenes, th... Read More

Guest Review by NewOrleansVamp

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/30/2021 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
We arrived near Midnight- there was no waiting in line. The monsters gave it their All! Great Maze in the pitch dark. Never knew what was behind the n... Read More

Suggested Improvements:
Crawling monsters in the woods give chase.

Guest Review by Isaac

Rating:
Visited: 10/12/2019 | Recommended: ❌ No

What They Liked Most:
After paying for the 3 attractions and waiting in line for 2 hours for the first attraction it wasn't scary at all. I took my 2 nephews with me ... Read More

Suggested Improvements:
have entertainment while waiting in lines. clearly mark your lines. diversify your actors costumes and don't let them break character. just al... Read More

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Only used to verify you’re human — never published.
Would you recommend it?
Rate the Details

All required. These help provide better recommendations for our new “Haunt Advisor” custom haunt recommendations feed. to get yours and start earning Haunt IQ!

Tap any i for what a question means, or Didn’t notice if it passed you by.

Scare Factor *
Characters *
Sets, Props & Effects *
Atmosphere & Story *
Pacing & Flow *
Length & Price *

Overall Score: /5

Rate the six above and your score appears here.
Your Review

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.