Frightworld Americas Screampark Review (2019)

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Final Score: 8.9/10

Quick Facts

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Runtime63 Minutes
MPD 2.10
TouchNo Touch
This attraction was reviewed by Team Haunt Crew on September 28, 2019.

Summary

Welcome to Frightworld America’s Scream Park! They offer five terrifically horrifying attractions all under one roof! The attractions are all very distinct, detailed, and excellently done. There are a variety of scares, big and small, that will make even the biggest, baddest, and toughest, quiver. So, you think you’re brave enough? We aren’t so sure, we think Tiny will petrify you!

How the hell did you find yourself here in some dingy, dark, damp basement filled with barrels that smell toxic? What are those sounds that seem to be coming from behind the walls? It’s the sounds of the Nightstalkers… If you stick around too long in this haunt you may become dinner for these mutant creatures with gnarly teeth created by radioactive waste, or maybe you’ll become one of those creatures yourself!

From a social media frenzy to a creative and distinctive haunted attraction, Storm Area 51 is just what the name promises! If you have ever wanted to delve into Area 51 and find out the truth behind the conspiracy theories, this is your chance. In this haunt you have found your way onto a top secret US Air Force base and are searching for evidence of aliens. It looks like you’ll have all the evidence you need, too bad during your secret excursion what’s been kept hidden at Area 51 all these years, has just escaped.

While the theme behind Eerie State Asylum may be one you are familiar with, it is doubtful you’ve ever experienced it like this before. You have entered the decaying remains of an abandoned asylum where patients were once tortured. As you explore the rooms and corridors panning the beam of your flashlight around the light begins to dim and flicker. What a time to have forgotten to check the batteries! On top of that you now suddenly realize that you are not alone! There are still insane patients loose in the building and you better find yourself a quick exit if you don’t want to end up becoming a permanent resident…

Up next is Grindhouse, what can we say? You come across an old beaten down cabin in the woods overgrown with vegetation, several severed body parts hanging from the porch roof, and you still decided to ‘just take a quick peek’? There won’t be any returning from that quick peek because the crazy inhabitants already know you’re there! One thing is for sure, they want to slaughter you, but who knows whether they will invite you to be dinner…

You made it! A day late maybe, but still, you have finally arrived at Eeriepalooza Fear Festival! Let the headbanging and mosh pits begin! You can hear the music going strong, but where is everyone? Wandering around you stumble across a clown, yes, of all things a clown, dancing in front of the main stage. There’s another clown by the concession stands. Why clown’s? Your day was already messed up from arriving late, but that’s no longer your biggest concern, now you need to get the hell out of here before you find out how the creepy clowns stole the show!
The entertainment (and terror) you’ll experience will have you trembling with happiness (or fear) on your way home to have sweet dreams (probably nightmares) remembering all the lovely (spine-chilling, creepy, gory, need I go on?) details of your evening spent at Frightworld America’s Scream Park!

Nightstalkers Reloaded (9.1)
Storm Area 51 (8.74)
Eerie State Asylum (9.16)
Grindhouse (8.82)
Eeriepalooza Fear Festival (8.68)

Cast8.33

After interviewing Steve, the director of operations, we learned that all of the actors at FWASP must go through an audition process and have special training. They go to “Boo School” and learn how to scare people in a variety of different ways. The actors show up an hour and a half before the haunt opens to prep themselves, sit for application of makeup, and get their costumes on. It is clearly evident that the cast are masters of their craft. Just seeing the way they move, allows themselves to become fully enveloped in their characters, and showing persistence in… Read More…

Costuming9.05

Nightstalkers Reloaded (9.15): In Nightstalkers Reloaded, the creatures were truly a one-of-a-kind creation. These creatures had two very distinctive features. The masks, created in-house, featured sunken in droopy eyes and large gnarled teeth with nasty decrepit-looking wrinkled skin. Detailed makeup added to the overall effect along with the dark ragged clothing that blended into the surroundings. You will definitely need to experience these Nightstalkers for yourself! Storm Area 51 (9.15): Aliens’ Roswell Grays’ Extraterrestrials’ whatever you want to call them, you’ll make first contact here! The alien actors wore light gray skin tight suits which had dark gray staring eyes.… Read More…

Customer Service9.43

It’s impossible to miss this haunt from the outside of the attraction, there was an enormous Stay Puft Marshmallow Man that was clearly visible from far away. There was plenty of free parking and there was no mud like haunted attractions located in rural areas because of the paved lot. There was an outdoor queue leading inside to the ticket booth which was efficient and moved quickly. As most of us know, many haunted attractions utilize porta potties which are often times scarier than the attractions themselves! That is not a concern at FWASP because there is a clean, albeit… Read More…

Atmosphere9.6

When you first arrive in the parking lot at Frightworld America’s Scream Park, you may wonder what you are doing at an Asian Food Market that looks surprisingly like an old Wal-Mart building. But no need to fret! The other end of the building has a large banner advertising the entrance to FWASP. The external decor does not seem like much but the second you enter the building you are transported from the city into a dark eerie countryside where unknown horrors await. The first thing you will see is a wooden fence covered with corn stalks which wraps around… Read More…

Special Effects9.12

Nightstalkers Reloaded (9.28): The sounds within Nightstalkers Reloaded were very unnerving and made us feel as if we were deep underground with the ever present sound of dripping water. There were also sections of silence that increased suspense and had us on our tiptoes. Nightstalkers seemed to have a fascination with mannequins. The mannequin animatronics are truly amazing, they are all made in house, and were much quieter than most that we see at haunts. We did feel that the timing could be adjusted on some of the animatronics to make them strike out at different sections of the group.… Read More…

Theme8.89

Frightworld America’s Screampark had five drastically different and exceptionally creative themes. All five haunts were easily identified based on their outside appearance and the themes within were well executed. The location of this haunted attraction did not fit with the themes of any of the attractions because it was located inside an old Wal-Mart building. With the number of attractions and variety of themes presented, there was not a way to tie it all together. This really did not detract from the attraction. The atmosphere created within the building was so surreal that you felt as if you were in… Read More…

Scare Factor8.14

Nightstalkers Reloaded (8.5) Within the dark confines of this decaying apocalyptic world, you will yourself faced with fantastically frightening creatures that have gnarled teeth coming after you while uttering otherworldly clicking sounds! Nightstalkers Reloaded did an excellent job of removing us from this world and dropping us into another time and place altogether. The detailing of the scenes created an appallingly realistic apocalyptic feel that would cause unease in anyone that entered. The Nightstalkers attacked from all directions, coming out from completely unexpected places providing scares for everyone in our group. Mainly, it seemed, that the types of scares were… Read More…

Entertainment & Value9.05

Frightworld America’s Scream Park is certainly one of the more interesting haunted attractions that our group has visited over the years. We felt that it really provided a good “bang for your buck”… or should I say, “scare for your buck”! General admission is $30.00 with the option to purchase VIP Frightpass tickets at a cost of $42.00 each. They also offer an option for those who may not have the time to go through all the attractions (or maybe they are just too scared to?) with the availability of the 2 House Combo Ticket for $18.00 with an optional… Read More…

Know Before You Go

  • All-Indoor Attraction
  • Food/Concessions
  • Gift Shop/Souvenirs
  • Hi-Tech Attraction
  • Indoor/Outdoor Waiting Line
  • Original Characters
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site
  • Free Parking

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2025Haunt Award
2023Highest RatedThe Asylum (9.9/10)

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Guest Review by Tom Cloutier

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/23/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
Absolutely worth a visit! The actors were great. Clean environment and the houses were very entertaining. One of the best Haunted Houses I've ... Read More

Guest Review by Jon Miller

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/13/2018 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
I’m 38 years old and a fan of haunted houses my whole life, been to probably over 75 different events. This event in buffalo is simply the best, it ha... Read More

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Overall Rating *
Scare Factor
Characters
SFX & Immersion
Pacing & Flow
Value
Would you recommend it?
Only used to verify you’re human — never published.

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.