This attraction was reviewed by Team Zombillies, Team Lone Wolf, and Team Brady Pack on September 20, 2025.Nashville Nightmare didn’t just give us nightmares – it made them larger than life! We ducked from the Boogieman himself, crept through the halls of a horror-filled high school, tumbled into twisted storybooks in Fairy Tale Hell, and even found ourselves trapped inside a UFO area in Area-X! Four full-blown haunts, each with its own story, make this destination a scream factory worth every second!
But the frights don’t stop at the exits. The midway here is alive with some of the most interactive characters we’ve ever seen! Add in a massive gift shop packed with spooky treasures, photo ops, and plenty of space to soak it all in, and you’ve got a night that delivers wall-to-wall fear and fun.
Make no mistake – this one should be on every haunt fan’s bucket list! But before you plan your trip, join us as we crack open the doors and show you what’s waiting inside each nightmare…
Overall Scores:
The Boogieman: 8.64
Fairy Tale Hell: 7.74
Horror High: 7.8
Area-X: 8.5
The Boogieman:
A paranormal investigator greeted us on the front porch of the decrepit old house. They warned us of the stories surrounding the home and the town it resided in before we embarked on our tour… and it wasn’t long before we found out those tales were all true! Ghouls with empty eyes and gaping black maws lurked throughout the haunt. Some members of the living world still appeared to be around – we saw them crawling on the floor toward us, trapped within walls, and running about bound in straightjackets with bloodied mouths (or possibly muzzles). An actor with saw blades (!), tearing out of their face and chained wrists, lurched at us from the darkness near a subway, where a vagrant attacked with a can of spray paint after we interrupted their attempt to create graffiti. Two cemetery workers came at us among the graves, wielding shovels and clicking gloves. A particularly clever actor rose silently behind our leading lady from their throne, then used the mouth of their mask to imitate the wicked laughter audio playing in their scene. In front of the haunted home, a spooky-looking young girl out front eerily sang “Ring around the rosie…” to our group. Some actors who had quick pop-out roles lingered for a few seconds, tilting their heads and contorting their bodies.
Most dialogue consisted of cries for help, screams and shrieks, and taunting laughs. Several actors were positioned for “e-prompt” scares that involved triggering a loud sound effect, so they had no lines of their own. At least one actor replied to a group member with “Yeah!” when asked if she was okay, but there wasn’t a lot of room for interaction with guests due to the focus on jump scares. The cast did interact well with their sets.
Fairy Tale Hell:
The Mad Hatter and Alice, greeting groups out front, did well with setting us up for our adventure through a land of fearsome fairytales. (Hatter measured each and every member of our party and assigned us various hats: someone was “fedora”, another person was “bowler”, etc. Great interaction!) Once we’d crossed the threshold into this sinister storybook, it quickly became obvious that previous visitors to the realm didn’t live happily ever after – they appeared to us pleading for help with getting out of there. The female arachnid cackled, “I see you!” when she caught us passing through her webbed lair. We would imagine that isn’t hard when you’ve got as many eyes as she did! Little Red Riding Hood, who’d already had an unfortunate run-in with the beast of the forest, warned us that “The wolf is coming!” and “He did!” when a group member asked if he was the source of her face wounds. Hansel rushed at us in the witch’s house with a cry of “She’s going to eat me!” Hey, better him than us. Later in the house, Davy Jones caught us in the deep and bellowed, “Dead men tell no tales!” This was most likely an audio line, but the actor played it off well.
Other than cries for help and the warnings from Little Red and Miss Spider, most dialogue came from audio effects the characters mimed along to. We did not encounter many living fairytale creatures on our adventure – many of the monsters and mythical figures came in the form of props and animatronics.
Horror High:
It was nearly time for class – and we’d better have studied and been on our best behavior. Two staff members prowled the line outside and were keeping a close eye on all of their unruly “students”. (We got a kick out of watching the male actor sternly lining customers up single-file!) In true Scare Factor fashion, it didn’t take long for us to get ourselves into trouble: the overzealous Hall Monitor came after us multiple times, demanding to see our hall passes, and nothing we presented seemed to appease him! We eventually ran into the Lunch Lady, who popped out and bellowed at us to “Hurry up and get to lunch! Growing children need to EAT!” Believe me, we wanted nothing to do with what they were serving in that cafeteria. Which the Chef apparently took offense to – bursting out at us silently and brandishing a knife! While performing in the school play, one “actor” had their brain exposed and appeared to even be missing their legs (!). We were repeatedly stalked by an actor who resembled either a faculty member or a student, wielding a severed head as a yo-yo. Some clever lines came from the split-faced instructor preparing us for the Final Exam: “Don’t mind my friend here,” he remarked, grabbing hold of a figure. “Hasn’t been the same since the budget cuts!”
There were quite a few gaps without a live person or anything happening around us. This house has room for more interactivity, and actors shouldn’t be shy about firing back if a customer responds to them.
Area-X:
Dr. Ridley greeted us at the facility’s entrance with a warning: aliens did indeed exist… and for the love of God, we’d better not touch anything! (Oh… and we could just disregard any rumors we might’ve heard about what goes on inside Area-X. Everything they do is for the betterment of humanity! And we could also ignore any sirens or alarms we heard inside.) As we explored the facility, we occasionally had a stray alien-human hybrid burst out to attack us or lurk in the corners of rooms, waiting for an opportunity to strike. More threats came in the form of corrupted scientists, who gleefully stalked and tried to zap us with tasers. Maybe they thought WE were aliens?! Many actor encounters were brief and meant for startle scares, but we did run into a hybrid sliding down a walkway.
Most of the haunt was well-covered by its cast, though we did see some gaps. Adding extra variation to the characters’ behaviors would make this house feel more realistic.
Out in the midway, the costuming was superior. These weren’t just queue actors; they were full-on characters, each rocking a complete look from head to toe. A towering winged demon stalked the grounds on stilts, spreading its massive wings for eerie photo ops. An exterminator stormed through the crowd, spewing fog and “bug spray” like he was cleansing the place of pests… or maybe just marking his next victims. We also crossed paths with a chilling doll, her soulless black eyes boring straight through us, plus clowns, a sparking slider, and several other fiends.
Boogieman:
The queue actress who gave us the fantasizing story and details, and ultimately the warnings that were behind the doors, at first glance, was unmasked and not in costume. However, we quickly discovered that she was a Ghost of Old Nashville tour guide, complete with little ghost dangly earrings, how cool! Most actors and actresses had costumes that fit the scenes and were intentionally designed. From the nuns, the worshipers of the Boogieman, down to the janitor, and we assume the Boogieman’s victims.
In a few cases, the skin could be seen behind the masks, but most characters wore costumes that matched their respective roles. Pig-tails, white sheets, and white faces were scattered throughout. My personal favorite had a face with hands that had long black claws wrapping around the skull and face of the character, and a gown similar to that of a priest; you could see the white, gigantic ribs peaking out from the top of the robe. Spooky level 666 if you ask me.
Fairy Tale Hell:
The line actors were well remembered at FairyTale Hell. Alice roamed around with a dirty and bloodied Alice dress, and Dead Alice makeup, and the Mad Hatter was dressed in ripped-up business attire, with a small amount of checkered sleeve sticking out, long red hair, and carried a measuring tape to take measurements – a perfect Fairy Tale duo to get us started on our journey.
The Queen of Hearts was dressed in a blue dress with blood-stained tears. A few witches graced us with their presence. One in particular had red hair and green foundation, while pirates wore dusty arms and costumes, as you would expect a pirate to look. There were also squid pirates with brown pirate hats, all dressed appropriately. Little Red Riding Hood stood out to us, though, looking like she was quickly thrown together compared to the rest of the fairytales. The actress who played in the spider room wore a black and white costume, her arms and face covered in white makeup, spider legs drawn near her mouth, and spider eyes covering the top of her face, making her look like a spider princess of some sort. The idea was beautiful, but the eyes looked like paper eyes glued to her forehead. These two characters appeared to be thrown together more quickly compared to the others.
Horror High:
We were introduced to the Green Goblin School teacher before we entered Horror High. Covered in green from head to toe, she had no amount of human colored skin showing. The hall monitor had neon makeup that glowed in the green, blue, and orange hallways and rooms at the beginning of the show. The Pumpkin-headed phantom of the Library graced us with his long black robe and pumpkin mask. Although we noticed that the mask might have covered his face, the hair on the back end didn’t give the costume a complete appearance. The kitchen cook popped into the Library, which didn’t exactly make sense.
Other costumes that were noticed included another green goblin secretary, some rebel students who wandered the halls in ripped-up uniform costumes and masks or makeup that matched the glow aesthetic of the rest of the cast. Overall, the cast effectively matched the theme of Horror High; most of the costumes and makeup appeared to have been created intentionally, which made our experience in Horror High more believable.
Area-X:
The aliens and experiments did not disappoint. Throughout the halls of the UFO in which we walked, we saw multiple deformed faces of potential experiments from the aliens that have taken over this small section of Nashville, Tennessee. From half-ripped-off faces to a military man turned alien himself, we were impressed with the costumes and makeup presentation of Area-X.
This nightmarish crew was astounding to communicate with. They were helpful, and despite being in a world made for nightmares and spooks, they were cheerful, which brought sickening smiles to our faces.
The website has all the information you’ll need to know before going, such as dates and times of operation and a link to purchase tickets ahead of time. Guests can find the attraction very easily with GPS, and there are signs for proper parking, which is behind the building and free! Their Facebook page and website include general information on what customers can expect when they visit.
Follow the flames in the sky to the entrance! We had to make our way through a metal detector security check before being admitted, which we always like to see. Once we made it inside, it was super easy to navigate the facility, both inside and out! Shout-out for the washing stations at the portable restrooms!
The Boogieman:
As you enter this haunt, err, hell disguised as a funeral home, there is a classic story of the Boogieman turned sinister. Two boys went missing- some say you can hear them in the hallways- but more importantly, they were never seen again. Was it the Boogieman? Or could it be something only born from a true nightmare?
The spirits and demons in this house of daunting horror were a perfect mix of interactions for everyone in the entire group, and walking through the storyline of how the boogieman has haunted Nashville, TN, was not one I would soon forget. Especially after hearing the screams of those trapped in this hell… this haunt conveniently leads to the next, or you can go back out into the midway.
Fairy Tale Hell:
I love a good fairytale, especially one of Grimm’s tales. Disney turned demonic for your screaming pleasure with this Fairy Hell attraction. The pregame to this haunt was enjoyable as the Mad Hatter and Alice sized us up by measuring our heads for hats, but they were really sizing up whether we’d make it through this tale alive!
Whether you’re a fan of WonderLand or Big Bad Wolf, there’s plenty to keep you thrilled and cautious about which twisted character in the dark is coming next. We feel like additional cast members would increase the immersion inside this attraction. This haunt conveniently spat us out right into the Shop of Horrors, AKA the gift shop.
Horror High:
Please, Mom, I don’t want to go to school! Single file line, and heads forward! This unearthly high starts you out with a glowing goblin teacher, telling you to button up so you know how to go back through school with the undead, and “DO YOU HAVE YOUR HALL PASS?” Alright, let’s get to class! The actors outside this attraction made it super fun to stand in line, and they prepared us to enter the school setting.
We’ll talk more about this later, but for those who look into partaking in the bars, before you get started with the actual haunt, you can settle into the Neon Coffin, a hidden bar – INSIDE a school! Gnarly! Grab a cocktail while you shake your nerves before meeting murderous cafeteria staff and zombie cheerleaders. Time your exit so that you don’t get clumped up with the other victims; otherwise, you will actually be in a single-file line like we did, and we ended up having to stop quite a bit towards the end of the haunt.
The creativeness of this storyline was Monster High cranked up to very scary, while members of the entire group witnessed some form of terror throughout. Right off the bus and into another attraction!
Area-X
Ever wanted an alien encounter? This one is perfect for you! Your group starts out being warned by a lab member informing you that aliens have broken loose! No worries, though; there are guards going after them… So they won’t get to you… maybe. Oh, and those gunshots? Those aren’t for you – as she slips a syringe back into her lab coat!
This haunt was so beautiful in the most creepy way possible! Inside, Xenomorphs, reptilians, and other galactic creatures were around every corner, giving this storyline a creative outlook for an alien breakout. Beware the FaceHuggers! Area-X was fun for the entire group; there was no safe place to be. As you avoid getting abducted, your exit is swift into the midway for more entertainment and Evil Boba.
The Boogieman:
Out of Nashville Nightmare’s four haunted houses, The Boogieman seemed to have the heaviest amount of detail and special effects: every scene was loaded with props. Several corpses and static figures were used; the looming doll-faced creatures in the swamp were particularly creepy, as were the masked demon worshipers (followers of The Boogieman, perhaps?). One of the most impressive sights we saw while walking through was the literal TREE crashing through a ceiling! The haunt was heavy on animatronics, too. To quote a group member: “Everywhere you look, there’s something moving!” Seemingly inanimate objects frequently sprang to life around us. We counted at least three actor-matronic puppets, of which one may have been automated (meaning an actor wasn’t operating it). Animated portraits were used on a couple of walls. At one point, we stumbled upon a towering beast with massive claws that reached up to the ceiling! There was a really cool effect involving the walls in a corridor that we won’t spoil here, but it was a favorite in our group.
True to the attraction’s story, there were a lot of dark spots, but lighting was used in appropriate tones for the other areas. Other lighting effects included simulated fire and overhead lights flickering like they’d go out at any moment. Sensory effects were also deployed: we were nearly swallowed by a DEEP swamp of fog and lasers. Strobes enhanced jump scares and animations. One scene had wind blowing. In the background, we could hear creepy music and ghastly, otherworldly noises. What could be making those?! We weren’t keen on finding out.
A few of the house’s scenes weren’t quite as heavy on detail as others. The graveyard in particular could’ve used some dirt on the plain floors, as we’ve seen at other haunts. One of the actor-matronics, a big grabber ghoul, seemed to have more wear and tear on it than the others.
Fairy Tale Hell:
This land of scary-tales boasted some amazing, and often larger-than-life props. Our spider-fearing group leader was not amused by the massive spider we encountered. A neat blacklit dragon lurked within a castle’s wall. Medusa’s lair contained bodies of former warriors turned to stone. The witch house from Hansel & Gretel included two child victims, and more children were “running” about outside. Many of the animatronics were equally impressive. Right off the bat, we were nearly chomped by a gigantic dragon puppet, and we even had an enormous hand reach out from the wall in an attempt to grab us! Sometimes, it was hard to tell what was a stationary prop and what would suddenly animate. Medusa towered over us at the entrance to her lair, and a giant snake head swayed to and fro. In the pirate scene, an enormous sea monster with a triton shook an unlucky victim.
Lighting came in colors tailored to every portion of the house. Strobes were used in multiple spots. We had to cross at least two walkways; one that swayed precariously over burning coals and another that bounced with each step. Water effects were also included. One of the more interesting effects was the tilted room on the pirate ship – staying upright wasn’t easy for several members of our party. For audio, we heard unsettling music, a medieval track, the wolf from Little Red Riding Hood howling, and night creatures. As with all of Nashville’s attractions, this house included a lot of good details and effects, and we only noticed some spots here and there where more could be added.
Horror High:
Horror High was a blacklight attraction, similar to the 3D houses many other haunts use, but without the glasses. There were loads of school-themed props: desks, blackboards, a skeletal football player, rows of lockers – just to name a handful. A rotted animatronic teacher hung from the ceiling of a break room with a vending machine nearby. In the windows of what seemed to be health class- as evidenced by a body being dissected and the teacher angry over our intrusion- lightning flashed outside, revealing bats. Tray after tray of grotesque food was available in the school’s cafeteria, and a stationary worker ladled green goo to feed the students.
A barrel in the storage room rattled to life as we passed it. The library’s shelves were littered with rows of books. From atop a flight of stairs, a zombified cheerleader descended upon us. The school’s theater had many neat things to look at, like giant monster heads and masks on the walls, and an entire set built for the play happening on stage. Fog provided a fun sensory effect. While we might’ve done well getting past the crazy students and staff, we narrowly avoided being smashed by an animated vehicle (!), rushing at us and blaring its horn. Good thing that fence was in the way!
We heard the aforementioned vehicle’s horn blaring throughout the house and the school bell ringing. There was music in the background, too, but it was hard to make out at times. Some props and scene details seemed to need a little work (refreshed paint, extra props, etc.).
Area-X:
We got a pretty good look as to what was really going on in the Area-X facility – and none of it was good. Alien babies floated in test tubes… including one where it was obvious the creature had broken out. Several large alien props and animatronics were used, along with two large robots. (One of the aliens was contained in a cage of red lasers. Neat!) A particularly creepy figure resembled a spider-human hybrid. We walked through a research lab littered with extraterrestrial bodies while computers glowed from the floor below, and cords were strung up everywhere. The gigantic flashing reactor with a body plastered to it was an impressive sight, and our group loved seeing the soldier in camo being “beamed up” by a spacecraft! We narrowly avoided an attack from an animatronic beast with a maw full of fangs when it unexpectedly lurched upward, rising well above its assumed height. Glistening, grotesque pods- egg sacs, maybe?- swayed in a hallway as a warning blared: whatever they were trying to hide in that bunker had officially gotten loose. Tall, spindly grey aliens watched us with curious black eyes as they presided over their latest experiment.
Shortly into our walkthrough, we found ourselves decontaminated by plumes of fog spewing down from the ceiling, and more fog was used in other areas of the haunt. A “mechanical”-sounding music track, for lack of a better word, provided background audio. We did indeed hear those sirens going off, as well as spoken warnings and alerts over the speakers.
In contrast to the more detailed rooms, we found a few spots that could’ve used more detail, like the concrete hallway with yellow and black caution markings.
21. How scary was it? (35% of score): 6.73
22. How well did they provide scares to everyone in the group? (15% of score): 7.11
23. How predictable were the scares? (25% of score): 8
24. How well did they provide a wide variety (types) of scares? (10% of score): 8
25. How strong was the ending / finale? (15% of score): 6.2
Scream Scores (by attraction):Boogieman:
Around 18 screams were heard from our group as we endured the possibility of being hunted and trapped by The Boogieman (not counting jumps). From below, up high, and side to side, we faced creatures, nuns, victims, and possibly the Boogieman itself. We watched sacrifices happen, people being tortured, a potential funeral director showed himself, children were frolicking in the halls, and the walls even fell in on us! Creatures terrorized us in a room full of fog. We walked through a cemetery, a sanctuary, and many coffins were displayed.
There was a section where mannequins and actors were dressed the same, and they were so incredibly still that we had a hard time distinguishing between the dead and the living. Some of the walk-throughs felt a little like walking with the living dead. An actor performed “Ring Around the Rosie” with one of our team members, making things extra unsettling. They utilized that nursery rhyme well. The end is where we potentially ran into the Boogieman, who gave us a single fright before we walked out the doors and were on our way to the next haunt. But in all seriousness, was that the Boogieman, or was he somewhere else hidden in the walls of the halls in which we walked?
Fairy Tale Hell:
We were warned or threatened, “It’s not safe to be in the woods at night.” We agree. Fairytale Hell brought us all four elements. They brought fire with the dragons. There was air, specifically one air blast that was out of this world, practically blowing us over. They brought several elements of Earth. We walked on several different textures, from wet to squishy mulch-like grounds, to squeaky wooden boards that mimicked what could be a pirate ship. There were fountains of water that created an atmosphere that raised hair on our bodies.
The Lagoon was stunning to look at, and the witch’s house that followed was a nice transition with several kid manikins locked up in a dungeon, like you would expect a witch’s dungeon to look. Overall, this haunt was very pretty. Each room could have been observed for an extended period; there was so much to look at. On the other hand, in most scenes, there were only a few actors. Most of the actors would hit the front of our group, but the other half of the group was missed entirely, leaving a lot of space between scares, especially for the back of the group. The finale was quiet and tricky. From snakes to most of the fairytale characters you can think of, to mermaids, pirates, spiders, witches, and a mirror maze that felt as if it were in the middle of a tree, Fairytale Hell did not end happily ever after, to say the least.
Horror High:
We were told we had to “fright to graduate, that even some students from last year were stuck in the nurses’ station. And there were green students who lay open, guts flowing from them on the tables in the nurses’ station.” We walked through a small library and then into the hall, where the hall monitor gave us a jump scare and directed us into a secret section where neon-lit coffin tables sit for the victims of Horror High to catch a break before the rest of the walk-through took place. Although this secret area was wicked, it did interrupt the flow of scares, but if you want to get your drink on, you’ll enjoy this secret nook!
When our team was finished with their little break, we walked through coffins, into a kitchen, a nurses’ station, a ballroom, another library, and through an entire school bus. While we were roaming the halls ourselves, we found it a little too quiet. Hardly any actors jumped out at us, and even some of the animatronics seemed off course or didn’t work at all. The actors present performed well, giving us scares that ranged from high to low. We did graduate, though, so it wasn’t too short of frights.
Area-X:
The alarm system sounded, and the lights began to flicker as we walked through the doors of this possible UFO. We were warned not to touch the experiments inside the walls, that touching the aliens wasn’t warranted. We wonder what would have happened if we had touched them… maybe one of us did, and perhaps that is why the pest control had to hit us twice in the midway. It didn’t seem like pleasant experimentation was taking place. Viles of in-progress experiments were taking place right before our eyes. The animatronics of the evening were more present than the actors. But the live experiments came at us with a vengeance. There truly was nowhere to run!
The sheer chaos and intensity of the actors in this attraction resulted in it being the second-highest-scoring attraction in this category during our visit. Props to the actors for working their magic, crawling on walls at us, coming at us from the floor, and being relentless in their attacks!
General Admission for all four haunts was $36.17 online (fees may vary, and prices go up the closer it gets to Halloween), which includes the four haunts. For VIP, it’s $60, which includes many of their other side attractions. Know ahead of time that tickets have to be purchased online only! If you get there and haven’t bought them, there will be a QR code outside for you to do so on your phone, but the earlier you buy, the better chances you have of getting into this attraction.
Not including attraction intros, we spent a total of 30.4 minutes inside the haunts. When considering the general admission price on the night of our visit, this brings the MPD (minutes of entertainment received per dollar spent) to 0.84. While this is lower than the average of 1.0 that we see most often, experiencing the set design alone is worth the admission price. We do recommend visiting earlier in the season. We only got backed up inside one haunt due to lines, and we visited in September.
For an additional cost, besides the haunts and screams, inside the midway were snacks and drinks to refuel the victims… err, customers, so they can keep going through all the fun there is to have. There are hidden bars for those interested (and who are 21+), and there was a boba stand on the night of our visit. They also had their Zombie Apocalypse Training Facility (gellyball), Clown Alley, Mini escapes, a photo booth to pick up your printed photos, and more. Don’t forget to stop by the Shop of Horrors gift shop, where they offer a large variety of items.
Included with your admission into the haunts is access to the midway, where actors roamed and terrorized us from the moment we arrived until we exited the attraction! There were also numerous photo-op areas to capture unforgettable memories of the night with large creatures and other decor. We could have spent days in the midway!
Nashville Nightmare is one of the most high-tech haunts around, and it’s not every day you get the chance to cross paths with alien lifeforms… or green teachers.
1016 Madison Square, Nashville, Tennessee 37115
