Portals of Fear Review (2023)

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Final Score: 8.34/10

Quick Facts

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Runtime20 Minutes
MPD 1.00
TouchNo Touch
This attraction was reviewed by Team Houdini on October 15, 2023.

Summary

There’s nothing like your first time… visiting a new haunt, that exhilarating feeling you get as you wait outside. We’re perpetually brimming with excitement whenever we stumble upon fresh haunts to explore, particularly when they crop up in our neck of the woods. You never really know what to expect, right? Typically, we stroll in with our expectations set on the lower side of the spectrum. New haunts are like sprouting saplings in the vast forest of the haunt industry, and it’s a real treat to witness them in their fledgling stages, anticipating where their sinister roots will delve in the future.

Enter Portals of Fear, a relative newcomer to the scene, now treading through its second ‘full’ season. Nestled in West Mifflin, Pennsylvania, at the hallowed grounds of the old James Lavelle Catholic School, this tale of terror has its roots back in 2018 when it was nothing more than a modest charity haunt for a local youth group at the parish. While its heart remains steadfastly non-profit, it’s undergone quite the transformation over the years, adopting the moniker ‘Portals of Fear’ just last year.

The mastermind behind this nightmarish spectacle, Charles, and his family, were initially roped in to lend a helping hand. He had a local yard haunt, you see, and eventually, he migrated his arsenal of eerie equipment and boundless creativity into the school, birthing the spine-chilling show we have the pleasure of experiencing today. But I’ll leave it to Charles to spin you that yarn, for he tells it far better than I ever could.

Now, it’s time to see what lies beyond the Portals of Fear.

Cast8.19

We were beckoned to enter an unassuming door. What lay behind it was a trip down memory lane, akin to my days in a Catholic school from my youth, a no-nonsense nun awaited us on the other side, her office bathed in the warm glow of retro nostalgia. She fixed her stern gaze upon me as I dared to open the door without a knock, only to be met with an exasperated query: “Who enters my office without knocking?” Not one to back down, I decided to knock, much to her obvious chagrin. Her voice cut through the air, loud… Read More…

Costuming8.21

The attention to detail in the costuming was nothing short of impressive. From the carefully crafted masks and makeup to the thoughtfully chosen attire, every element came together seamlessly, enhancing the distinct personas and seamlessly blending into the overarching theme of each area. For example, the nun we encountered early on; she was clad in a complete habit, her face shrouded in dark makeup that lent her an eerie, sunken appearance. A young bride, hauntingly beautiful in her traditional white wedding dress and ghostly makeup, embodied the essence of a spectral bride. The Mayan sacrifice segment featured figures draped in… Read More…

Customer Service9.81

Our journey commenced in the unassuming backside of the venue, where we dutifully parked and then ventured towards the waiting line. However, it quickly became apparent that a crucial detail had slipped our grasp: tickets were a hot commodity, and we found ourselves ticket-less. It turns out we had missed a glaring sign directing ticket-seekers to the front. We have to admit, following directions isn’t exactly our strong suit. Speaking of directional mishaps, I may have made a few wrong turns navigating the dark, winding roads that seemed determined to lead us up imposing hills, spiraling into the location. I… Read More…

Immersion8.23

Out in the front, there’s a fall festival ambiance that greets you with open arms. You’ll spot metal drum fires, their grinning jack-o’-lantern faces etched into the flames, beckoning you towards warmth. The air carries the mouthwatering scent of food and drinks, and there’s even a spot for creative souls to try their hand at pumpkin painting as well as the promise of thrilling raffles that adds a dash of suspense to the mix. Strolling towards the building’s side where the haunt’s ominous entrance lurks, you’ll be guided by helpful signs, each one a tantalizing glimpse into the various realms… Read More…

Special Effects8.17

Sound played a role in specific scenes and areas, though it didn’t always leap to the forefront of our senses. In some spots, the music or sound effects remained discreet, even going unnoticed. While the lavish set designs were certainly enough to captivate most folks, we couldn’t help but think that an added score or distinct music for each scene or even a continuous backdrop would have taken the whole experience to a cinematic level. It’s not a complaint, mind you, but more of an idea for elevating the journey to an even grander scale. What really blew us away… Read More…

Scare Factor8.05

It wasn’t just about the dazzling set pieces; it was a full-blown rollercoaster of fright that had us leaping out of our skin, invoking deities, and, well, contemplating what might’ve transpired in our trousers, we should have worn the brown pants. The scares ran the gamut, making sure to target every nerve in our small group. There were those classic startle scares, you know, the ones that make you yelp and put your hands up to stop an attack and deafening noises seem to manifest out of thin air. Then came the intimidation factor, where these unsettling individuals got right… Read More…

Entertainment & Value8.25

Beyond the main event, Portals of Fear did sprinkle in a bit of queue line entertainment to keep us engaged while we waited. We couldn’t help but wish for a tad more while standing in line, but our patience was rewarded once we stepped inside. For the thrifty haunt-goer, the $20 ticket price came as a pleasant surprise, given that this year’s average has been hovering around $25. With an exploration time of just 20 minutes to delve into all the portals, it essentially translated to a minute per dollar spent, slightly below the average of 1.2 MPD for this… Read More…

Know Before You Go

  • All-Indoor Attraction
  • Food/Concessions
  • Original Characters
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2025Highest Rated
2025Haunt AwardThe Convenience Store
2025Haunt Award
2023Haunt Award

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Guest Review by Delena

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/15/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
This haunt keeps getting better each year

Guest Review by Danica

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/14/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
The hunted keeps getting better each year and a lot of new stuff each year!

Guest Review by Jennifer Taylor

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/14/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
Anyone can jump out and scare you in a dark room. But this haunt had the best scenery, scare vibe and actors I have seen in a long time. Sensory stuf... Read More

Guest Review by Cj

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 10/14/2023 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
This haunt is absolutely amazing! Ever since it first open and til now it has most definitely grown. With the make up and costume designs they all got... Read More

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Overall Rating *
Scare Factor
Immersion & Sets
Characters & Actors
Pacing & Flow
Would you recommend it?
Only used to verify you’re human — never published.

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.