Thirteen years ago Jonathan had his friends over for their annual Halloween hangout. As usual, they played a game of manhunt. This time it was different, Jonathan was it.

He hunted each one of his friends down, murdering them with various tools from his shed. He finished off his kills with his own mother, who he left hanging in the woods.

This lead to what we know as The Mill Massacre. Jonathan quickly vanished, heading to the Conover Christmas tree Farm for refuge. As he was looking for a place to hide, a group of teens stumbled upon the farm. Just when the town thought this scary story was ending, a new chapter was just beginning.