Literally A Haunted House at Culbertson Mansion Review (2012)

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Final Score: 8.76/10

Quick Facts

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
TouchPossible
This attraction was reviewed by Team Zombillies on October 19, 2012.

Summary

The Culbertson Mansion is now in their 28th year of terrorizing New Albany, Indiana! This year, the volunteers that bring this historic building to life are honoring some new information that they have come across. It has been found that the mansion’s carriage house was owned by a couple that used to use it as a storefront to sell their hand-made dolls. Many of these are now on display for all to see, but they seem to be doing more than just giving visitors something to look at. It seems as though these ‘toys’ have had a spell cast upon them and they are not only demented, but ready to play with anyone who travels through these dark passageways. But don’t take our word for it; make sure that Culbertson Mansion, Literally, a Haunted House is on your list of haunts to see for the 2012 Halloween season!

Cast9.08

There are usually around 50 volunteer actors in and around the Culbertson Mansion’s carriage house, which is plenty to fill each scene without anyone stepping on anyone else’s toes. Before the season starts, the cast go through orientation and training sessions and are coached by veteran actors and managers to make sure they fit their parts. Actors are also evaluated and given options on what scenes they are best suited for so that their personalities match their characters. Most of the characters were believable, but some of them didn’t match the haunt’s ‘demented toy’ theme. Examples are the zombies, the… Read More…

Costuming8.69

Costumes are typically provided to actors by Culbertson Mansion and are usually found at local thrift stores. Later, they are modified, distressed and otherwise altered to make each character come to life! 3 to 4 airbrush artists are on-staff to make sure that each of the actors looks their best before each night begins. Masks are also typically purchased and later modified to help clarify what each character is supposed to be. Aside from the characters mentioned in the ‘Cast’ category, the rest of the crew matched the theme pretty well. Their costumes, makeup and masks were very well detailed,… Read More…

Customer Service8.99

If you don’t already know where the Culbertson Mansion is, it can be a little difficult to find. There aren’t many easily visible signs by the road and parking is located behind the property in a field across the railroad tracks. As you make your way up the sidewalk, a small set of stairs made more visible by rope lights will lead you to the ticket booth and two portable restrooms. A nice concession stand is located in the same tent as the ticket booth and friendly staff members offer customers t-shirts, souvenirs, snacks, drinks, hot food and warm beverages… Read More…

Atmosphere8.6

The Culbertson Mansion gets points on its looks by being an authentic mansion and its naturally-intimidating exterior, but it’s not the scariest-looking building from the main road having been recently restored and its plentiful lighting that cuts through the darkness. The carriage house, however, looks far more sinister and what we found inside reflects what we gathered from looking at the various props and d

Special Effects8.91

Most of the props and special effects at Culbertson Mansion are custom-made by some of the haunt’s very own crew members, but some of them have also been purchased from various haunt-related vendors. Many of the scenes are detailed well, but some rooms weren’t as elaborate as others. However, many of these original effects stood out to our review team: the demon emerging from the girl’s stomach, the barbed wire scene, the skeleton mother in the rocking chair, the casket ride, the rotating box, the entire floor being painted like an Ouija board, and the techniques used for other scene… Read More…

Theme8.58

The haunt’s theme this year is ‘deranged and demented toys’ in honor of some new information that was recently discovered about the carriage house, which is where the tour primarily takes place. Apparently, the building was previously owned by a couple that used it as a storefront to sell their hand-made dolls. Several of the characters and scenes helped make this theme more apparent, but there were others that didn’t seem to fit as well, such as the zombies and nurses.

Scare Factor8.24

The culmination of Culbertson Mansion’s year-round efforts provide customers with scares they won’t soon forget! Scares range from creepy stares and chants during the s

Entertainment & Value8.97

General admission to Culbertson Mansion is $13 and VIP speed-pass tickets are currently unavailable. It took our review group an estimated 20-25 minutes to complete our tour of the carriage house which comes out to almost 2 minutes per dollar spent. That being said, Culbertson Mansion is one of the better priced haunts in Kentuckiana and when combined with what you will experience inside, it makes them very competitive with other haunts in the area, so make sure that you visit Literally, A Haunted House this Halloween season!

Know Before You Go

  • Covered Outdoor Waiting Line
  • Family Friendly
  • Gift Shop/Souvenirs
  • Indoor/Outdoor Attraction
  • Old-School (Low-Tech)
  • Original Characters
  • Outdoor Waiting Line (Covered)
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site
  • Special Events
  • Dirt/Grass Lot
  • Free Parking
  • Overflow Parking Available
  • Street Parking

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2025Shout OutLost Soul (Kevin Warth)
2025Shout OutBanshee (Haley Logsdon)
2024Shout out AwardChainsaw Maniac (Blake Lockman)
2024Shout out AwardThe Conjoined Twins (Heather Purlee and Shamaya Coston)
2023Haunt AwardBest Storyline / Theme

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Overall Rating *
Scare Factor
Immersion & Sets
Characters & Actors
Pacing & Flow
Would you recommend it?
Only used to verify you’re human — never published.

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.