Literally A Haunted House at Culbertson Mansion Review (2014)

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
Final Score: 8.84/10

Quick Facts

Moderate ScaresModerate Scares
TouchPossible
This attraction was reviewed by Team Zombillies on October 17, 2014.

Summary

Culbertson Mansion has been in the industry for 30 years in 2014 and ’30 is the new black!’ This year, they’ll trick you into summoning the demons from the Mansion’s past so you can bear witness to all sorts of frightening fan favorites. From zombies and ghosts to dentists and chainsaws, you never know what will be waiting for you around the next corner! For an original take on classic-style scares in an old-school haunt, visit Culbertson Mansion in New Albany, Indiana’ Literally, A Haunted House!

Cast8.62

Around 30 volunteer actors will come out to haunt you on a typical night at Culbertson Mansion. The clown and his buddies were some of the first we met and kept us thoroughly entertained as we waited in line. During our walkthrough, we noticed many believable performances! Among those were Giltine, the zombies, the ‘creature of the darkness,’ and the dentist, just to name a few. Giltine seemed nice as first and was very interactive with our group, but we soon found out she was quite the contrary. The zombies were also very realistic, so don’t get too close if… Read More…

Costuming8.7

This year, you’ll find quite a variety of different characters at the Culbertson Mansion! Many of them seemed to be sporting airbrushed makeup and a few of them even had sharp teeth and colored contacts! Some of the characters that we came across during our tour include sacrificing cultists, a demented dentist and his aggressive assistant, a wall-poised, possessed girl, some overzealous zombies, and several different demons that definitely displayed diabolical demeanors! Several of the creatures and characters, such as the zombies, looked pretty believable with their worn, tattered, and bloody clothing, while others went for a more-authentic approach with… Read More…

Customer Service9.15

We knew we were at the right place when we saw the yellow ‘Literally, a Haunted House’ banner flying above Main Street out in front of the Mansion! Free parking is available on each side and/or behind the building, across the railroad tracks. Snacks, spooky souvenirs, hoodies, and t-shirts are available near the ticket booth and there are places to sit if you grab a bite to eat. Friendly staff members could also be found near the ticket booth/concession areas, as well as at the front of the queue line. Two or three roaming actors kept the crowd entertained during… Read More…

Atmosphere9

Before we even made it out of our vehicle, we could see fog escaping from the Mansion’s back yard and rolling down the street! The closer we got, the more we wondered if we should enter! Just the Culbertson Mansion’s Victorian-style exterior can be rather creepy looking at night! Exhaustive pleas for help and wicked chants were escaping from within the cemetery and other creepy music could be heard, which really helped set the mood to enter the attraction. Multiple roaming and very believable actors also interacted with us and prepared us to enter.

Special Effects8.53

The effects our crew came across during the hellacious awakening include a mixture of items that have been both purchased and created in-house. Ominous sounds, thick fog, and hypnotizing smells filled the air in some of the scenes, and increased their authenticity! Mood-setting scene detail and lighting existed, as well as other realistic, bloody, and creepy d������������������cor that helped in bringing the scenes and theme to life! Some of the unique effects our group came across include a ghastly spirit, Culbertson’s infamous and unique coffin ride, a spinning room, a demon-summoning book, a misleading statue, a fireplace opening into ‘Hell’,… Read More…

Theme9.6

Due to 2014 being the haunt’s 30th frightening season, they are celebrating with the theme of ’30 is the new black.’ This consists of their ‘greatest hits’ from over the years, bringing back some very dark creatures that have been ‘set free.’ As soon as we stepped through the gates of the graveyard, we were on our own and could tell something very evil had taken over! Once inside the carriage house, we met a woman who assured us she wasn’t crazy, and talked us into chanting a spell out of her book to make the cult practices and bad… Read More…

Scare Factor8.2

Multiple types of frights were directed at us during our daring exploration, including powerful chanting, intimidating weapons, suspenseful surroundings, alarming sounds, aggressive characters, and an interruption of an intense sacrificial ceremony that we quickly scrambled away from before we were next! Several unexpected distractions were used and effectively caught our group off-guard. Canny hiding spots were also revealed, and several were even combined with unforeseen ankle grabbing, which really nailed us! Everyone in our group was targeted by all of the characters, so none of us were left out of the scares! A run-in with the dark creature and its… Read More…

Entertainment & Value8.9

Ticket prices to try your luck at escaping the horrors that have been set free inside this carriage house are priced at $14.00 per soul this season. Our group was stuck within these dark, spirit-infested walls for around 14 minutes, putting this value at 1 minute of entertainment per dollar spent. Although this is closer to an average value, this is still one of the lowest ticket prices in the area! Combine the lower ticket price and original, creepy fun that is to be had at Culbertson Mansion, and you have yourself a frightful deal! Have little ones that are… Read More…

Know Before You Go

  • Covered Outdoor Waiting Line
  • Family Friendly
  • Gift Shop/Souvenirs
  • Indoor/Outdoor Attraction
  • Old-School (Low-Tech)
  • Original Characters
  • Outdoor Waiting Line (Covered)
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site
  • Special Events
  • Dirt/Grass Lot
  • Free Parking
  • Overflow Parking Available
  • Street Parking

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2025Shout OutLost Soul (Kevin Warth)
2025Shout OutBanshee (Haley Logsdon)
2024Shout out AwardChainsaw Maniac (Blake Lockman)
2024Shout out AwardThe Conjoined Twins (Heather Purlee and Shamaya Coston)
2023Haunt AwardBest Storyline / Theme

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Overall Rating *
Scare Factor
Immersion & Sets
Characters & Actors
Pacing & Flow
Would you recommend it?
Only used to verify you’re human — never published.

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.