When it came to the actual scare factor, there was definitely a pretty big range between the different haunts. Tooth Fairy was surprisingly relentless and had some genuinely scary moments. The actors weren’t afraid to get right in your face, and the scares kept coming throughout the haunt. Paranormal Inc. also did a really good job keeping you on edge. Actors could come at you from all different angles, there were some really loud noises, and the darkness made it hard to know where the next scare was coming from.
Conjuring was easily the scariest haunt for us. It was fast paced from beginning to end, the actors got right up close and even touched you, and there were some really tight spaces that added another level of suspense. The loud noises and audience participation also kept you guessing about what was coming next. The finale was especially good and was a great way to end the haunt.
Jason was still really scary despite the conga line. There were a lot of different angles to the scares, plenty of loud noises and pop outs, and the timing was really good. The biggest difference between Jason and Conjuring was predictability. Jason was very well timed, but once you got into the rhythm of the haunt, some of the scares were easier to anticipate.
Silver Scream was probably the least scary for us. The actors were working hard, but there just wasn’t quite enough for them to work with in the haunt itself. A lot of the scares felt predictable, so you could see them coming. Slaughterhouse was also on the less scary side. There were some good moments, but there were noticeable dead spots and the chainsaw scares weren’t always reliable. A lot of the scares felt similar, so there wasn’t as much variety to keep you guessing.
Paranormal did a great job mixing up its scares. You had actors coming from different directions, loud noises, darkness, and some bigger effects, and the timing was really well done. The variety kept you from knowing exactly what was coming next. The Tooth Fairy also did a good job of keeping you guessing because the scares changed from scene to scene rather than relying on the same type of scare over and over.
One thing I thought all of the haunts did well was making sure there were scares for everyone in the group. Some were definitely more intense than others, but you weren’t just watching the person in front of you get scared. Conjuring and Paranormal had the widest variety of scares and did the best job of keeping everyone involved.
The finales were another area where there was a noticeable difference between the haunts. Conjuring had a really strong ending, and Jason also finished on a high note. Paranormal had a big animatronic at the end that gave you one more memorable moment before you walked out. Silver Scream and Slaughterhouse could both benefit from stronger finales that give you one last big scare before sending you back into the park.
Overall, Conjuring and Paranormal stood out the most for us when it came to actually being scary, mainly because of the variety, timing, and unpredictability of the scares. Tooth Fairy was also much more intense than we expected. Even when some of the other haunts weren’t as scary, the actors were still putting in the effort, and there are some relatively simple changes that could make those experiences much more effective.
See Less