Nightmare Forest Haunt Park Review (2013)

Final Score8.67/10
8 categories scored
Scariness
High IntensityHigh Intensity

Summary

Returning for it’s 31st season in 2013, this legendary haunt is now known as Nightmare Forest Haunt Park, bringing you 5 attractions at one location for one ticket price! New this season you can experience Hawthorne’s Circus Bizarre, a creepily entertaining sideshow where you may witness some very painful and awing stunts! During your adventure through Nightmare Forest, you will once again get the opportunity to step into some of your favorite horror movie scenes and come face to face with the villains within them! A few of these are Hellraiser, Nightmare on Elm Street, Sinister, and Texas Chainsaw Massacre… Read More…

Cast8.33

On an average evening there are around 40 actors at the park who audition in their scenes for paid spots before and during the season, which gives them the incentive to play their roles well. Though this was a descent number of actors to have, there was still quite a bit of dead space where additional actors could’ve delivered entertainment and startles. The majority of the characters used dialogue that matched their scenes very well which made them believable, but there were some that didn’t say much at all where needed. Some of the impressive characters that stood out to… Read More…

Costuming8.68

Costuming used throughout the attractions is mostly purchased from thrift stores and vendors to later be modified to fit the characters’ scenes including masks, while a few of them are made by the haunt’s staff. There are 4 makeup artists who work at the attraction applying realistic touches to the characters with a new technique they started using this season. Despite it being so dark in several areas, from what we could tell, all of the costuming matched the scenes they were used in and went along with their individual themes. Some of them were very realistic while others could… Read More…

Customer Service8.8

Four large, white signs were lined down the highway near the entrance to Otter Creek Park making it easy to find. Once you pull in, continue down the spooky lane of cedars trees until a flagger can be spotted directing traffic into the parking lot. There is plenty of free, grassy and some paved parking, but this area is not lit until you get to the ticket booth area so be careful. Portable restrooms can be found conveniently located in the parking area and behind the ticket booth. If you have any questions or concerns, helpful staff can be found… Read More…

Atmosphere8.25

When we first arrived and started our way towards the ticket booth, the sounds of banjos, chainsaws, loud blasts, screams, and yelling escaping from within the haunt park helped in letting us know we had arrived at a haunted attraction! The sideshow provided plenty of entertainment before we entered, but some roaming characters could help provide unsuspected startles and interaction with the line in-between shows along with some haunt themed music to get them prepared for what they may experience inside the attractions. Dueling banjos could be heard the entire time we were in the corn, but were also heard… Read More…

Special Effects8.67

Special effects are both purchased items and items designed by the haunt’s crew. Until this season, we weren’t aware that the folks who bring the horror to Otter Creek Park every year only have 3 weeks to set everything up before their opening night! There is a variety of special effects used including some that we’ve never seen anywhere else. In Nightmare Forest, scenes were decorated realistically and helped us to distinguish what movies they were from. Trail of Terror had the most attention to detail, making us feel as if we were in a real city as a result… Read More…

Theme9

Each attraction at the haunt park has its own diverse theme. Nightmare Forest starts you off in its lobby before unleashing you into the home of many familiar horror movie villains who want YOU as their next victim! In Trail of Terror you will get to experience what happens when the living turn into the flesh-craving, living dead that have overrun Hazelwood and Woodbury. In Nightmare Harvest, recognizing the sound of dueling banjos is not the only thing you need to worry about! The twists and turns within the corn and those who reside there may never let you out!… Read More…

Scare Factor8.7

Scares are delivered on different levels from stalking whispers and threatening dialogue to creepy timbers, startles, unsuspected surprises, all-out chainsaw attacks and a zombie violently munching on a corpse! They seemed to target the middle of our small group, so everyone got to experience the scares. A great deal of the characters in Nightmare Forest followed behind us through their scenes and into the forest away from their scenes, which had us constantly turning around and looking behind us! Some of the movie characters we came across were much more intimidating and authentic than they were last season which helped… Read More…

Entertainment & Value8.92

On-site general admission to all 5 attractions will cost you $20.00 per person . However if purchased in advance online, they are just $18.00 per person! Speed pass tickets can be purchased for $30.00 at the hautn or $26.00 online, which allows a shorter wait time on very busy nights. It took our group around 30 minutes to escape from the haunted attractions and an additional 15 minutes to witness the stunts performed by Circus Bizarre, making this a very competitive price! Single-night, unlimited-entry tickets are also available at the haunt for $35.00 per person or $30.00 online, which grants… Read More…

Know Before You Go

  • Covered Outdoor Waiting Line
  • Food/Concessions
  • Games/Midway
  • Gift Shop/Souvenirs
  • Indoor/Outdoor Attraction
  • Movie Characters
  • Original Characters
  • Restrooms/Porta Potties On-Site
  • Uncovered Outdoor Waiting Line
  • Free Parking

Watch Our Walkthrough

Youtube video

Awards

2024Haunt AwardBest Opening Scaremony (2024 – Team Zombillies)Fireworks, Monsters
2024Shout out Award(2024 – Team Zombillies)Ginger AKA Allison Marie
2024Shout out Award(2024 – Team Zombillies)Patches The Clown AKA Dacodea
2023Shout out Award(2023 – Team Zombillies)Gravedigger (Doug Graves) AKA Sage Sizemore
2023Shout out Award(2023 – Team Zombillies)Pennywise AKA Jimmy Johnson

Make It a Night: Nearby Reviewed Haunts

Guest Reviews

Guest Review by Beans

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 08/22/2026 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
Nightmare Forest was a really good, haunt and definitely worth checking out. The overall experience was a lot of fun, and there was a good mix of cree... Read More

Guest Review by Dustin

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Visited: 09/19/2025 | Recommended: ✅ Yes

What They Liked Most:
Went on a Saturday night and I'd go again. This isn't a walk-through in a warehouse. It's a real trail through real woods and the dark ... Read More

Suggested Improvements:
No it was perfect!

Share Your Experience

Been to this haunt? Leave a guest review to help other thrill-seekers decide.

Only used to verify you’re human — never published.
Would you recommend it?
Rate the Details

All required. These help provide better recommendations for our new “Haunt Advisor” custom haunt recommendations feed. to get yours and start earning Haunt IQ!

Tap any i for what a question means, or Didn’t notice if it passed you by.

Scare Factor *
Characters *
Sets, Props & Effects *
Atmosphere & Story *
Pacing & Flow *
Length & Price *

Overall Score: —/5

Rate the six above and your score appears here.
Your Review

Reviews are moderated before appearing. Thanks for helping fellow thrill-seekers!

Experience Levels

MASTER: 100 reviews of 60 unique haunts in 10 years.

EXPERT: 50 reviews of 30 unique haunts in 5 years.

VETERAN: 15 reviews of 10 unique haunts in 3 years.

APPRENTICE: 5 reviews of 5 unique haunts in the past year.

NOVICE: Entry-level team.