Top Must-See Halloween Haunted Houses in Indiana for 2024
As Halloween 2024 approaches, TheScareFactor.com has curated a list of the top must-see haunted houses in Indiana, ensuring thrill-seekers experience the biggest, best, and scariest haunts this season. Our selections are based on our comprehensive reviews (where available), popularity metrics, and social media presence, featuring only the most terrifying and immersive attractions. Whether you’re searching for a local haunt or planning a spooky road trip, our state-by-state guides provide detailed summaries of each top attraction, along with links to in-depth reviews, our in-depth listings. Dive in, explore the best haunts, and prepare for an unforgettable Halloween adventure!
#13: Haunting at the Hannah House (Indianapolis, IN)
Haunting at the Hannah House is a haunted attraction held at the historic Hannah House, known for its eerie ambiance and paranormal activity. The mansion, built in 1858, provides a spooky backdrop for the haunt experience. For 2024, the Haunting at the Hannah House returns and will be open on select nights, including weekends from late September to early November. In addition to being a haunted attraction, Hannah House is a popular site for ghost tours and paranormal investigations due to its history of supernatural occurrences. Visitors often report mysterious sounds and sightings during these events, adding to the attraction’s chilling atmosphere.
#12: Forsaken Forest (Richmond, IN)
Forsaken Forest, a haunted trail produced by Black Forest Productions, is a new haunted attraction that debuted in the fall of 2023. This attraction offers a spooky outdoor experience, featuring various themed scenes designed to scare and entertain visitors as they walk through the forest. With high ratings from visitors, Forsaken Forest has quickly become a must-see haunt for those in the area!
#11: Evansville Nightmare Factory (Evansville, IN)
Evansville Nightmare Factory is another brand-new haunted attraction that takes place in a repurposed old factory. For 2024, this haunt is rekindling some pre-existing haunt characters from the area and introducing them to a new ‘home!’ Guests can expect to be split up from each other, encounter sloping floors and crawlspaces, along with phobia-targeted scare tactics.
Video coming soon!
#10: Scarevania (Muncie, IN)
Scarevania Haunted House offers a unique Halloween experience complete with a cabaret stage, a tarot card reader, the new Pumpkin Pulp store, and an oddities and curiosities tent. Though slightly smaller than in previous years, the haunt remains a favorite for visitors looking for an exciting and eerie adventure with original characters.
#9: Unreal Nightmares (Jasonville, IN)
Unreal Nightmares is an all-indoor haunted attraction that started in 2018. This 18,000 square foot haunt is designed to challenge visitors with a combination of scare tactics and escape room-style puzzles. The attraction is known for its immersive experience, where guests must find clues and navigate through various terrifying environments. The haunt includes features like free parking, a gift shop, and themed events, and is noted for its dark scares and intense, dimly-lit atmosphere.
#8: House of Anguish at The Culbertson Mansion (New Albany, IN)
House of Anguish at the Culbertson Mansion (formerly known as ‘Literally, A Haunted House) is a long-standing haunted attraction that has been operating since 1985. Set in the Carriage House of the historic Culbertson Mansion, this haunt changes its theme every year, focusing on stories of past residents affected by a malevolent presence known as Anguish. The haunt is known for its authentic scares, rooted in the building’s eerie history, with reports of unexplained occurrences. Proceeds from ticket sales support the mansion’s restoration efforts.
#7: Shattered Nightmares (Terre Haute, IN)
Shattered Nightmares is an all-indoor haunted attraction known for its immersive storytelling experience, featuring original characters and a variety of spooky effects that keep visitors on edge. Tour guides pace customers throughout the haunt, ensuring groups don’t run into each other and add trepidation to upcoming scenes, perfectly timing each scare experience. Shattered Nightmares offers free parking and includes several themed areas that challenge guests with a mix of claustrophobic spaces, darkness, and well-timed animatronics.
#6: Necropolis Underground (Indianapolis, IN)
Necropolis Underground is one of the city’s largest haunted attractions. Spanning multiple haunts in the building’s underground level, this haunt features four main attractions: Nightmare House, Cemetery of the Damned, Dead and Breakfast, and The Bunker. Each offers a uniquely-themed experience, blending high-tech special effects with traditional scare tactics. The haunt is well-known for its many well-hidden hiding spots, detailed set designs, and interactive actors who keep the tension high. In addition to the main attractions, Necropolis Underground includes the Dead City Festival midway area, which offers games, axe throwing, escape rooms, and more. The haunt operates several special events throughout the year, including Valentine’s Day, Christmas, Summertime, and other seasonal shows, which maintain the same intensity as their Halloween offerings. For those looking for a comprehensive and diverse haunted experience in Indianapolis, Necropolis Underground is a must-see haunt in central Indiana!
#5: Malice Manor (Clarksville, IN)
Malice Manor is a 10,000+ square foot indoor haunted attraction. Open since 2019, Malice features a variety of original characters and high-energy performances, ensuring a unique experience each season. Visitors are warned they may be touched as they navigate through the manor’s twisted corridors, encountering the eerie creations of the haunt’s designers. Special events are also hosted throughout the year, adding different themes and scares.
#4: Hysterium Haunted Asylum (Fort Wayne, IN)
Hysterium Haunted Asylum offers an intense haunted house experience designed to immerse visitors in their deepest fears. The haunt features an asylum theme where guests navigate through an eerie hospital taken over by deranged residents and staff. In addition to the main attraction, Hysterium offers a mini escape room challenge called “The Tool Shed” for an extra fee, allowing guests to bypass lines if they succeed.
#3: Haunted Hills Haunted Attractions (Merrillville, IN)
Haunted Hills Haunted Attractions offers a complete Halloween experience with multiple haunted attractions, including the ‘Haunted Hills Hospital,’ the ‘Sick Billy Sideshow,’ and the ‘Fear Lab Haunt Experience.’ Known for its rock-show atmosphere and intense scares, Haunted Hills provides a mix of indoor and outdoor scares across its various attractions. The event features concessions, a gift shop, and paid parking. The 2024 season runs from late September through early November, with special events and dates.
#2: Nightmare on Edgewood (Indianapolis, IN)
Nightmare on Edgewood in Indianapolis, IN, is a highly-rated haunted attraction known for its intense scares and full-contact, interactive experience. For 2024, this attraction is set to feature three main haunts: Unhinged, The Factory, and Conley Farm. The haunt allows for contact, meaning actors may touch you, adding to the intensity of the experience. With a mix of original characters, Nightmare on Edgewood offers a unique blend of terror and creativity, ensuring their spot on our list of must-see haunted houses in Indiana for 2024!
#1: Thirteenth Hour (Indianapolis, IN)
The Thirteenth Hour is an immersive haunted house event with multiple attractions, each a chapter in a larger narrative. For the 2024 season, the haunted house has expanded and now includes new attractions such as the Widows Walk Cemetery, The Cathedral of Souls, and the Sharpe Family Orphanage. Each attraction offers a unique storyline and setting designed to immerse visitors fully in the experience. In addition to the main haunted attractions, The Thirteenth Hour also offers special experiences and themed events throughout the year, such as laser tag and ‘Valentine Haunt – Love is Blind.’ Featuring movie-quality set designs, elaborate costumes, and high-tech special effects to enhance the scares, The Thirteenth Hour is definitely a must-see haunt in Indiana for 2024!
As you plan your trips to haunts this season, be sure to check our Reviews Page for updated reviews and ratings, as well as our YouTube Channel for possible videos of some of the top must-see haunted houses in Indiana for 2024!
