13th Hour Rising Haunted Hayride
84 Merrit Road, Fulton, NY
Cast: 7.61
Costuming: 7.75
Customer Service: 7.9
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.65
Scare Factor: 6.56
Entertainment & Value: 7.62
Blood Manor Haunted Attraction
359 Broadway, New York, NY
New York City’s Premier Haunted Attraction
Cast: 7.96
Costuming: 7.95
Customer Service: 7.93
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.43
Scare Factor: 8.08
Entertainment & Value: 8.07
Crooked Descent Haunted Attraction
2 Campion Road, New Hartford, NY
Cast: 8.64
Costuming: 7.95
Customer Service: 9.18
Immersion: 7.61
Special Effects: 6.9
Scare Factor: 8.55
Entertainment & Value: 7.13
Dark Matter Scream Works
4430 Dewey Avenue, Rochester, NY
Cast: 6.72
Costuming: 8.73
Customer Service: 9.25
Immersion: 8.3
Special Effects: 8.35
Scare Factor: 7.47
Entertainment & Value: 8.38
Darkside Haunted House
5184 NY-25A, Calverton, NY
Be Prepared to Be Scared!
Cast: 8.6
Costuming: 8.83
Customer Service: 8.88
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.69
Scare Factor: 8.66
Entertainment & Value: 8.2
Demon Acres
341 Co Rte 36, Hannibal, NY
Cast: 8.32
Costuming: 8.44
Customer Service: 9.6
Immersion: 8.43
Special Effects: 8.79
Scare Factor: 8.21
Entertainment & Value: 7.88
Frightmare Farms Haunted Scream Park
4816 NY-49, Fulton, NY
Cast: 8.68
Costuming: 8.86
Customer Service: 9.89
Immersion: 8.25
Special Effects: 8.78
Scare Factor: 8.37
Entertainment & Value: 9.2
Frightworld Americas Screampark
1001 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY
Where Nightmares Come True
Cast: 9.2
Costuming: 9.07
Customer Service: 9.9
Immersion: 8.96
Special Effects: 9.33
Scare Factor: 8.36
Entertainment & Value: 8.63
Gateways Haunted Playhouse
215 S Country Road, Bellport, NY
Cast: 8.91
Costuming: 9.3
Customer Service: 9.25
Immersion:
Special Effects: 9.78
Scare Factor: 9.68
Entertainment & Value: 9.6
Grimsleys Gorge
455 Main Street, Phoenix, NY
Cast: 8.6
Costuming: 8.66
Customer Service: 8.7
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.16
Scare Factor: 7.32
Entertainment & Value: 8.68
Headless Horseman Hayrides and Haunted Houses
778 Broadway, Ulster Park, NY
Cast: 8.4
Costuming: 8.96
Customer Service: 7.88
Immersion:
Special Effects: 9.22
Scare Factor: 8.72
Entertainment & Value: 10
Night Terrors Haunted Farm
4193 NY-7, Schoharie, NY
Haunted hayride and corn maze!
Cast: 8
Costuming: 8.1
Customer Service: 9.35
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.8
Scare Factor: 8.08
Entertainment & Value: 8.83
Nightmare Manor NY
3333 West Henrietta Road, Rochester, NY
Cast: 7.54
Costuming: 9.33
Customer Service: 8.83
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.22
Scare Factor: 8.38
Entertainment & Value: 7.4
North Country Nightmares Haunted Hayride
17940 US RT 11, Watertown, NY
Cast: 8.59
Costuming: 7.65
Customer Service: 8
Immersion: 7.4
Special Effects: 7.45
Scare Factor: 7.28
Entertainment & Value: 8
Pure Terror Screampark
1010 NY-17M, Monroe, NY
Beyond the Limits of Fear!
Cast: 7.6
Costuming: 7.6
Customer Service: 7.83
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.1
Scare Factor: 7.5
Entertainment & Value: 7
Scared by the Sound
380 Downing Drive, Youngtown Heights, NY
New York’s premier haunted house located in Yorktown Heights
Cast: 8.1
Costuming: 8
Customer Service: 8
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.9
Scare Factor: 7
Entertainment & Value: 6.85
Six Flags Darien Lake Fright Fest
9993 Allegheny Road, Darien Center, NY
Fright by Night
Cast: 6.79
Costuming: 6.03
Customer Service: 8.3
Immersion: 7.04
Special Effects: 7.38
Scare Factor: 6.69
Entertainment & Value: 6.75
Slaughterland Screampark
666 Barrier Road, Binghamton, NY
Cast: 8.13
Costuming: 7.64
Customer Service: 8.29
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.61
Scare Factor: 8.49
Entertainment & Value: 8.99
Tagsylvania
3037 NY-352, Big Flats, NY
The Southern Tier of Fear!
Cast: 8.13
Costuming: 8.4
Customer Service: 7.87
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.61
Scare Factor: 8.46
Entertainment & Value: 8.68
Terror Field
7 Columbia Street, Clyde, NY
Cast: 9.48
Costuming: 9.1
Customer Service: 9.65
Immersion: 8.63
Special Effects: 8.8
Scare Factor: 9.08
Entertainment & Value: 9
The Fright Nights
1 LePage Place, Syracuse, NY
You will know the meaning of the word Fright!
Cast: 7.78
Costuming: 8.09
Customer Service: 8.76
Immersion: 8.6
Special Effects: 8.01
Scare Factor: 7.68
Entertainment & Value: 9.63
These are the haunted house reviews available for Halloween haunted attractions in New York. One of our Scream Teams has written each review based on our standard criteria, which apply to all haunted attractions. These criteria range from Cast and Costuming to Special Effects, Customer Service, and, of course, the Scare Factor! Click on a haunt’s name to go to their most recent review, or if we have older reviews available, you can find them in the “Archives” section to see how they’ve changed over the years.
NOTE: ONLY haunts with published (or pending) reviews in New York can be found on this page! If you’d like to see a list of every haunt that we have listed in New York, visit our full New York Haunted House Directory.
Find haunted house reviews using our complete list of Halloween haunted attractions in New York that have been reviewed by our professional Scream Teams! Also, these Review Teams can be found reviewing haunted houses all across the country. The Scare Factor’s Scream Teams also review the biggest, best, and scariest hayrides, scream parks, and corn mazes in the land! Follow The Scare Factor and our other teams on YouTube to find our latest walkthrough videos, behind the scenes tours, haunted house and horror conventions, and more! New York is full of haunted houses and our network of review teams is always growing. If you don’t see the attraction you’re looking for here, try looking through our New York Haunted House Directory. If you still can’t find the haunt you’re looking for, Contact Us to request that we add it to our directory, and we’ll try to accommodate you as soon as possible. Thanks for visiting and, as always, Happy Haunting!
The Scare Factor provides reviews and directory listings for Halloween haunted houses, haunted trails, haunted hayrides, scream parks, and other types of haunted attractions.
All rights reserved. Copyright 2025©️