Indiana Haunted Attraction Reviews

All Scream Team reviews for 2025 and earlier.

2025
Abattoir A Haunted Attraction
Vincennes, Indiana
Final Score 8.15
This group couldn’t wait to “meat” me. And once I entered the doors of this... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212020
2023
Bakers Junction Haunted Train
Bloomington, Indiana
Final Score 6.76
If what you seek is a nostalgic trip down haunt-lovers lane, then climb aboard the... Read More...
Read 2023 Review
2025
Crazy Caretakers Haunted House
Holland, Indiana
Final Score 7.72
When we drove down a little side street and came across a building with a... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
2020
Criminally Insane
Crown Point, Indiana
Final Score 8.83
Just an hour southeast of Chicago lies Criminally Insane (CI) in Crown Point, Indiana. This... Read More...
Read 2020 Review
2025
Facing Evil A Dead Birds Production
Evansville, Indiana
Final Score 8.47
Facing Evil, A Dead Bird’s production has brought scares and fear to Evansville, Indiana, for... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
2024
2025
Fear Itself at Legend Park
Mishawaka, Indiana
Final Score 8.01
Since 2008, Fear Itself at Legend Park has been unleashing terror in Mishawaka, Indiana. What... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
2020
2025
Forsaken Forest
Richmond, Indiana
Final Score 8.09
As our intrepid little group cautiously begins our trek into the woods, a bell tolls... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
2024
2023
Fright Manor
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 7.58
I might’ve escaped the snarling saws of the lunatics nipping at my heels, but my... Read More...
Read 2023 Review
20222021202020192018
2020
Grissom Maze Of Terror
Peru, Indiana
Final Score 7.93
There’s an 18,000 sq ft haunted attraction hidden within the Grissom Air Reserve Base known... Read More...
Read 2020 Review
2017
2025
Hanna Haunted Acres
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 8.16
Thick fog rolled through the sky, and in the distance we could see a large,... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212019
2025
Haunted Hills Haunted Attractions
Merrillville, Indiana
Final Score 8.92
We found ourselves in Indiana this season (poaching in other nearby states for local attractions)!... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220202019
2024
Haunting at the Hannah House
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 7
It’s been a decade since these doors creaked open to visitors searching for a hauntingly... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
2025
House of Anguish at the Culbertson Mansion
New Albany, Indiana
Final Score 8.59
If you live in or anywhere near New Albany, Indiana, you’ve probably visited- or at... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212019
2024
Hysterium Haunted Asylum
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Final Score 8.1
Step into the madness at Hysterium Haunted Asylum in Fort Wayne, Indiana, where the patients... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
20222021202020192018
2021
Indiana Fear Farm
Jamestown, Indiana
Final Score 7.79
Are you looking for farm-fresh fun? Look no further than Indiana Fear Farm! KD Farms... Read More...
Read 2021 Review
2018
2025
Indy Scream Park
Anderson, Indiana
Final Score 7.83
It was an early September night, and while the leaves hadn’t yet turned, fall was... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212019
2024
Malice Manor
Clarksville, Indiana
Final Score 8.81
I’m afraid you’ve picked a poor night to visit,’ the mysterious and darkly-dressed lady before... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
20232022202120202019
2025
Necropolis Underground Haunted Attractions
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 8.35
For decades, Necropolis Underground has been haunting the Indianapolis, Indiana area, delivering terror from deep... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212020
2025
Newburgh Civitan Zombie Farm
Newburgh, Indiana
Final Score 7.8
​Newburgh Civitan Zombie Farm is located in Newburgh, Indiana, and is in its 52nd year... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242014
2024
Nightmare on Edgewood
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 9.32
Ready to star in your own horror flick? How about three? Nightmare on Edgewood is... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
20232022202120202019
2022
Psycho Path IN
French Lick, Indiana
Final Score 7.33
In the countryside of Sleeping Bear Retreat in French Lick, Indiana, lies Psycho Path Haunted... Read More...
Read 2022 Review
2020
2015
Scarevania Haunted House
Muncie, Indiana
Final Score 8.72
Our 2015 visit to Scarevania took place during their 9th season and several changes were... Read More...
Read 2015 Review
2014201320122011
2023
Shattered Nightmares
Terre Haute, Indiana
Final Score 8.3
In the distance, a shadowy structure materialized, veiled in the haunting radiance of emerald lights.... Read More...
Read 2023 Review
20192016201520142013
2024
Streapers Nightmare
Peru, Indiana
Final Score 7.89
In the wake of the hurricane, as the rain poured down and the winds howled,... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
2021
2024
The Asylum
Evansville, Indiana
Final Score 9
From a home haunt to Evansville, Indiana’s newest haunted attraction, Evansville Nightmare Factory, The Asylum... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
2019
The Columbia City Haunted Jail
Columbia City, Indiana
Final Score 7.6
Although this was our first visit to the Columbia City Haunted Jail (CCHJ), they are... Read More...
Read 2019 Review
2017
The Jacob Vogel Scare
Versailles, Indiana
Final Score 6.16
The Jacob Scare Haunted Woods is a local attraction to the Versailles, Indiana area that... Read More...
Read 2017 Review
2024
The Nightmare Factory Wabash
Wabash, Indiana
Final Score 7.9
Brand new to the scene, Nightmare Factory Wabash wasted no time making a big impression.... Read More...
Read 2024 Review
2025
The Thirteenth Hour
Indianapolis, Indiana
Final Score 9.44
Once a humble home haunt, The Thirteenth Hour has evolved into one of the most... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220202019
2025
Unreal Nightmares
Jasonville, Indiana
Final Score 9.25
Unreal Nightmares features a unique style of haunted house that mixes an escape room with... Read More...
Read 2025 Review
20242023202220212020
2023
When Darkness Falls Haunted Trail
Columbus, Indiana
Final Score 7.78
Once the sun goes down, the woods of CERA Sports Park & Campground undergo a... Read More...
Read 2023 Review

Top 13 Ranking for Indiana

  1. The Thirteenth Hour (2025) 9.44
  2. Nightmare on Edgewood (2024) 9.32
  3. Unreal Nightmares (2025) 9.25
  4. The Asylum (2024) 9.00
  5. Haunted Hills Haunted Attractions (2025) 8.92
  6. Criminally Insane (2020) 8.83
  7. Malice Manor (2024) 8.81
  8. Scarevania Haunted House (2015) 8.72
  9. House of Anguish at the Culbertson Mansion (2025) 8.59
  10. Facing Evil A Dead Birds Production (2025) 8.47
  11. Necropolis Underground Haunted Attractions (2025) 8.35
  12. Shattered Nightmares (2023) 8.30
  13. Hanna Haunted Acres (2025) 8.16
Subscribe!