Abattoir A Haunted Attraction
321 N 2nd Street, Vincennes, IN
Score: 8.02 | Mins./$: 0.75
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2020]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 7.73
Costuming: 7.45
Customer Service: 9.89
Immersion: 8.14
Special Effects: 8.88
Scare Factor: 7.05
Entertainment & Value: 7.91
Bakers Junction Haunted Train
7898 South Fairfax Road, Bloomington, IN
Cast: 6.66
Costuming: 6.33
Customer Service: 8.4
Immersion: 6.83
Special Effects: 5.88
Scare Factor: 6.56
Entertainment & Value: 7.19
Criminally Insane
226 South Main Street, Crown Point, IN
Cast: 8.62
Costuming: 8.85
Customer Service: 9.53
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.76
Scare Factor: 8.45
Entertainment & Value: 8.93
Evil on Erie
1240 Erie Street, Lafayette, IN
THE EVIL RETURNS
Cast: 8.34
Costuming: 8
Customer Service: 9.34
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.04
Scare Factor: 8.1
Entertainment & Value: 7.94
Facing Evil A Dead Birds Production
3800 Claremont Ave, Evansville, IN
Cast: 7.31
Costuming: 5.44
Customer Service: 9.4
Immersion: 7.19
Special Effects: 8.74
Scare Factor: 5.38
Entertainment & Value: 8.82
Fear Itself at Legend Park
14130 McKinley Hwy, Mishawaka, IN
The Only Thing we Have to Fear is… FEAR ITSLEF!
Cast: 7.71
Costuming: 8.38
Customer Service: 9.23
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.43
Scare Factor: 8.04
Entertainment & Value: 8.31
Forsaken Forest
5970 IN 121, Richmond, IN
Cast: 7.73
Costuming: 7.76
Customer Service: 9.65
Immersion: 7.4
Special Effects: 7.41
Scare Factor: 8.07
Entertainment & Value: 7.81
Fright Manor
350 Anniston Drive, Indianapolis, IN
Score: 7.58 | Mins./$: 0.54
Read [2023] Review
Archives: [2023][2022][2021][2020][2019][2018][2017]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 7.25
Costuming: 6.97
Customer Service: 9.74
Immersion: 6.75
Special Effects: 7.07
Scare Factor: 7.89
Entertainment & Value: 7.63
Grissom Maze Of Terror
2251 Randolph Street, Peru, IN
Feel The Terror
Cast: 7.51
Costuming: 7.71
Customer Service: 8.81
Immersion:
Special Effects: 8.03
Scare Factor: 7.85
Entertainment & Value: 8.09
Hanna Haunted Acres
7323 East Hanna Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
Indianapolis’ Haunted Theme Park
Score: 8.09 | Mins./$: 0.98
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2019]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 7.6
Costuming: 8.43
Customer Service: 9.82
Immersion: 8.45
Special Effects: 7.95
Scare Factor: 7.49
Entertainment & Value: 8.06
Haunted Hills Haunted Attractions
7611 E 81st Ave, Merrillville, IN
THE INSANITY RETURNS THIS OCTOBER!
Cast: 9.14
Costuming: 9.23
Customer Service: 9.58
Immersion: 9.42
Special Effects: 8.77
Scare Factor: 8.66
Entertainment & Value: 9.29
Haunting at the Hannah House
3801 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
Indy’s Only REAL Haunted House!
Cast: 7.57
Costuming: 7.62
Customer Service: 8.22
Immersion: 7.15
Special Effects: 6.13
Scare Factor: 6.78
Entertainment & Value: 6.07
Horror House Haunt
28051 Moore Drive, West Harrison, IN
Want to join us at The Colony? If you make it to the meet up location, board the bus and we will try More
Cast: 7.23
Costuming: 6.85
Customer Service: 9.06
Immersion: 6.59
Special Effects: 6.89
Scare Factor: 6.78
Entertainment & Value: 7.97
House of Anguish at the Culbertson Mansion
914 East Main Street, New Albany, IN
Southern Indiana’s Longest Running Haunted House
Cast: 8.67
Costuming: 8.32
Customer Service: 9.45
Immersion: 7.88
Special Effects: 8.23
Scare Factor: 8.16
Entertainment & Value: 7.65
Hysterium Haunted Asylum
4410 Arden Drive, Fort Wayne, IN
Your darkest deepest fears are in Hysterium!
Score: 8.1 | Mins./$: 1.23
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2022][2021][2020][2019][2018][2017]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 8.25
Costuming: 7.72
Customer Service: 9.15
Immersion: 7.76
Special Effects: 8
Scare Factor: 7.96
Entertainment & Value: 7.96
Indiana Fear Farm
6736 South 500 West, Jamestown, IN
Indiana’s Scariest Haunted Hayride and Slaughter Barn!
Cast: 6.78
Costuming: 7.81
Customer Service: 8.99
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.97
Scare Factor: 7.45
Entertainment & Value: 7.64
Indy Scream Park
5211 South New Columbus Road, Anderson, IN
Be Afraid…Be Very Afraid!
Score: 8 | Mins./$: 0.96
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2019][2018][2016]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 7.31
Costuming: 7.66
Customer Service: 9.78
Immersion: 8.26
Special Effects: 7.8
Scare Factor: 7.58
Entertainment & Value: 8.52
Malice Manor
640 Providence Way, Clarksville, IN
Step Inside the Insanity
Score: 8.81 | Mins./$: 0.52
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2020][2019]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 8.84
Costuming: 8.79
Customer Service: 9.69
Immersion: 8.99
Special Effects: 8.64
Scare Factor: 8.64
Entertainment & Value: 8.49
Necropolis Underground Haunted Attractions
7130 Western Select Drive, Indianapolis, IN
Score: 8.47 | Mins./$: 0.89
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2020]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 8
Costuming: 8.26
Customer Service: 9.71
Immersion: 8.58
Special Effects: 8.23
Scare Factor: 8.01
Entertainment & Value: 9.22
Newburgh Civitan Zombie Farm
5466 South Vann Road, Newburgh, IN
Cast: 7.62
Costuming: 7.72
Customer Service: 9.77
Immersion: 7.1
Special Effects: 8.18
Scare Factor: 5.61
Entertainment & Value: 8.25
Nightmare on Edgewood
1959 S Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN
Scaring Indy’s South-side for 40+ years
Score: 9.32 | Mins./$: 1.09
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2020][2019][2018][2017]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 9.25
Costuming: 9.09
Customer Service: 9.75
Immersion: 9.44
Special Effects: 9.11
Scare Factor: 9.31
Entertainment & Value: 9.39
Psycho Path IN
2773 South County Road 1000 West, French Lick, IN
Cast: 7.32
Costuming: 7.12
Customer Service: 8.89
Immersion: 7.75
Special Effects: 6.24
Scare Factor: 7.23
Entertainment & Value: 7.38
Shattered Nightmares
1609 Lafayette Avenue, Terre Haute, IN
Cast: 8.2
Costuming: 8.21
Customer Service: 9.27
Immersion: 7.65
Special Effects: 8.5
Scare Factor: 8.19
Entertainment & Value: 8.25
Stillwell Manor
1704 East 60th Street, Anderson, IN
Score: 7.84 | Mins./$: 1.78
Read [2022] Review
Archives: [2022][2021][2020][2019][2018][2017]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 7.6
Costuming: 8.11
Customer Service: 9.4
Immersion: 8.17
Special Effects: 7.49
Scare Factor: 7.28
Entertainment & Value: 7.79
Streapers Nightmare
71 West 7th Street, Peru, IN
Your Adventure Awaits
Cast: 7.82
Costuming: 7.27
Customer Service: 9.28
Immersion: 7.55
Special Effects: 7.57
Scare Factor: 7.58
Entertainment & Value: 8.42
The Asylum
1545 N 7th Ave, Evansville, IN
Cast: 9.35
Costuming: 9.06
Customer Service: 9.94
Immersion: 9.46
Special Effects: 9.04
Scare Factor: 8.1
Entertainment & Value: 8.7
The Columbia City Haunted Jail
116 East Market Street, Columbia City, IN
The Haunted Jail – Not Your Average Haunted Attraction
Cast: 6.54
Costuming: 7
Customer Service: 9.2
Immersion:
Special Effects: 7.5
Scare Factor: 7.78
Entertainment & Value: 7.48
The Jacob Vogel Scare
3530 East Olean Road, Versailles, IN
The Jacob Scare
Cast: 6.82
Costuming: 6.08
Customer Service: 7.44
Immersion:
Special Effects: 5.25
Scare Factor: 5.75
Entertainment & Value: 6
The Nightmare Factory Wabash
200 Chestnut Street, Wabash, IN
Cast: 7.46
Costuming: 8.22
Customer Service: 8.83
Immersion: 8.01
Special Effects: 7.39
Scare Factor: 7.74
Entertainment & Value: 8.31
The Thirteenth Hour
915 South Shortridge Road, Indianapolis, IN
3 A New Kind of Fear
Score: 9.24 | Mins./$: 0.97
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2020][2019][2018][2017]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 9
Costuming: 9.37
Customer Service: 9.75
Immersion: 9.44
Special Effects: 9.56
Scare Factor: 8.62
Entertainment & Value: 9.53
Unreal Nightmares
117 South Meridian Street, Jasonville, IN
Score: 9.19 | Mins./$: 2.3
Read [2024] Review
Archives: [2024][2023][2022][2021][2020][2019]
Scores From Latest Review:
Cast: 9.44
Costuming: 9.31
Customer Service: 9.08
Immersion: 9.04
Special Effects: 9.31
Scare Factor: 8.81
Entertainment & Value: 9.32
When Darkness Falls Haunted Trail
3989 South 525 East, Columbus, IN
Visit us as the night falls upon the woods of Ceraland Park
Cast: 7.38
Costuming: 7.76
Customer Service: 9.32
Immersion: 7.52
Special Effects: 7.57
Scare Factor: 7.43
Entertainment & Value: 8.16
These are the haunted house reviews available for Halloween haunted attractions in Indiana. One of our Scream Teams has written each review based on our standard criteria, which apply to all haunted attractions. These criteria range from Cast and Costuming to Special Effects, Customer Service, and, of course, the Scare Factor! Click on a haunt’s name to go to their most recent review, or if we have older reviews available, you can find them in the “Archives” section to see how they’ve changed over the years.
NOTE: ONLY haunts with published (or pending) reviews in Indiana can be found on this page! If you’d like to see a list of every haunt that we have listed in Indiana, visit our full Indiana Haunted House Directory.
Find haunted house reviews using our complete list of Halloween haunted attractions in Indiana that have been reviewed by our professional Scream Teams! Also, these Review Teams can be found reviewing haunted houses all across the country. The Scare Factor’s Scream Teams also review the biggest, best, and scariest hayrides, scream parks, and corn mazes in the land! Follow The Scare Factor and our other teams on YouTube to find our latest walkthrough videos, behind the scenes tours, haunted house and horror conventions, and more! Indiana is full of haunted houses and our network of review teams is always growing. If you don’t see the attraction you’re looking for here, try looking through our Indiana Haunted House Directory. If you still can’t find the haunt you’re looking for, Contact Us to request that we add it to our directory, and we’ll try to accommodate you as soon as possible. Thanks for visiting and, as always, Happy Haunting!
The Scare Factor provides reviews and directory listings for Halloween haunted houses, haunted trails, haunted hayrides, scream parks, and other types of haunted attractions.
All rights reserved. Copyright 2025©️